金属学报, 2026, 62(6): 1128-1136 DOI: 10.11900/0412.1961.2024.00400

研究论文

带材厚度对Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8纳米晶软磁合金磁畴结构和高频磁性能的影响

施博文1, 李艳辉,1, 冯拓1, 王雨2, 蒋丽1, 于凤云1, 杨陆2, 张伟,1,3

1 大连理工大学 材料科学与工程学院 大连 116024

2 西南应用磁学研究所 四川省磁性材料工程技术研究中心 绵阳 621000

3 东北大学 冶金学院 沈阳 110819

Effect of Ribbon Thickness on Magnetic Domain Structures and High-Frequency Magnetic Properties of Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8 Nanocrystalline Soft Magnetic Alloy

SHI Bowen1, LI Yanhui,1, FENG Tuo1, WANG Yu2, JIANG Li1, YU Fengyun1, YANG Lu2, ZHANG Wei,1,3

1 School of Materials Science and Engineering, Dalian University of Technology, Dalian 116024, China

2 Sichuan Engineering Research Center for Magnetic Materials, Southwest Institute of Applied Magnetics, Mianyang 621000, China

3 School of Metallurgy, Northeastern University, Shenyang 110819, China

通讯作者: 李艳辉,yhli@dlut.edu.cn,主要从事非晶/纳米晶软磁合金和纳米多孔合金等功能材料研究;张 伟,wzhang@dlut.edu.cn,主要从事非晶态合金、纳米材料和磁性材料研究

收稿日期: 2024-11-28   修回日期: 2025-03-13  

基金资助: 国家重点研发计划项目(2022YFB3804100)
国家自然科学基金项目(52171153)
国家自然科学基金项目(52371149)

Corresponding authors: LI Yanhui, associate professor, Tel:(0411)84706400, E-mail:yhli@dlut.edu.cn;ZHANG Wei, professor, Tel:(0411)84706063, E-mail:wzhang@dlut.edu.cn

Received: 2024-11-28   Revised: 2025-03-13  

Fund supported: National Key Research and Development Program of China(2022YFB3804100)
National Natural Science Foundation of China(52171153)
National Natural Science Foundation of China(52371149)

作者简介 About authors

施博文,男,2000年生,硕士

摘要

为提高纳米晶软磁合金的高频磁性能,本工作研究了带材厚度(15~23 μm)对Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8纳米晶软磁合金的组织结构及静态和高频磁性能的影响规律,并通过磁畴结构表征分析了带材厚度对其高频磁化行为的影响机制。结果表明,不同厚度的快淬合金带材均呈现非晶态,843 K退火60 min后,形成相似的非晶+ α-Fe纳米晶双相组织,α-Fe的平均晶粒尺寸为11.0~11.6 nm。所有纳米晶合金带材的饱和磁通密度和矫顽力无明显差异,分别为1.35~1.36 T和0.5~0.6 A/m。纳米晶合金的高频软磁性能随带材厚度的减小而逐渐提升,薄带材的有效磁导率(μe)可在更高频率下保持稳定,且随频率增加的衰减较慢。15 μm厚度带材在100 kHz和1 MHz下的μe分别为17000和5200,远高于23 μm厚带材的14000和2900。减小带材厚度能显著降低单位质量铁心损耗(Pcm),在0.2 T、100 kHz和0.2 T、500 kHz条件下,15 μm厚带材的Pcm分别为67和811 W/kg,较23 μm厚带材分别降低38.0%和41.9%。损耗分离结果表明,薄带材较低的Pcm主要归因于涡流损耗和剩余损耗的降低。减小带材厚度可细化纳米晶合金的磁畴,有助于高频下磁畴旋转,从而提高高频磁导率、降低剩余损耗。

关键词: 纳米晶软磁合金; 高频损耗; 磁导率; 带材厚度; 磁畴结构

Abstract

The development of third-generation semiconductors has increased power density in electronic devices while increasing demands for high-frequency performance of internal soft magnetic materials. Fe-based nanocrystalline alloys are among the most promising candidates for high-frequency applications owing to their excellent comprehensive soft magnetic properties, including high saturation magnetic flux density (Bs), high permeability, and low core loss per unit mass (Pcm). However, further improvements in their high-frequency properties are required. This study prepared Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8 nanocrystalline alloy ribbons with 15-23 μm thicknesses by adjusting the Cu wheel speed. The effects of ribbon thickness on the structure and static/high-frequency magnetic properties of the nanocrystalline alloys were investigated. Furthermore, the high-frequency magnetization mechanisms of nanocrystalline alloys with varying ribbon thicknesses were examined through magnetic domain structure characterization. Results indicate that all as-spun alloy ribbons exhibit an amorphous structure and transform into a similar amorphous + α-Fe nanocrystalline dual-phase structure after annealing at 843 K for 60 min, with average α-Fe grain sizes of 11.0-11.6 nm. The static magnetic properties of all ribbons are nearly identical, with Bs and coercivities of 1.35-1.36 T and 0.5-0.6 A/m, respectively. On the contrary, the high-frequency soft magnetic properties improve with decreasing ribbon thickness. The effective permeability (μe) of thinner ribbons remains stable and exhibits milder attenuation with increasing frequency. At 100 kHz and 1 MHz, the 15-μm ribbon has μe of 17000 and 5200, respectively, which are substantially higher than the values of 14000 and 2900 for the 23-μm ribbon. Moreover, the thinner ribbons demonstrate reduced Pcm. At 0.2 T, 100 kHz and 0.2 T, 500 kHz, the 15-μm ribbon shows Pcm of 67 and 811 W/kg, representing reductions of 38.0% and 41.9%, respectively, compared with the 23-μm ribbon. Loss separation analysis indicates that the reduced Pcm of the thin ribbon is primarily attributed to decreased eddy current loss and residual loss. The decreased ribbon thickness refines the magnetic domains, facilitating domain rotation at high frequencies and improving high-frequency permeability while reducing residual loss.

Keywords: nanocrystalline soft magnetic alloy; high-frequency core loss; permeability; ribbon thickness; magnetic domain structure

PDF (2639KB) 元数据 多维度评价 相关文章 导出 EndNote| Ris| Bibtex  收藏本文

本文引用格式

施博文, 李艳辉, 冯拓, 王雨, 蒋丽, 于凤云, 杨陆, 张伟. 带材厚度对Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8纳米晶软磁合金磁畴结构和高频磁性能的影响[J]. 金属学报, 2026, 62(6): 1128-1136 DOI:10.11900/0412.1961.2024.00400

SHI Bowen, LI Yanhui, FENG Tuo, WANG Yu, JIANG Li, YU Fengyun, YANG Lu, ZHANG Wei. Effect of Ribbon Thickness on Magnetic Domain Structures and High-Frequency Magnetic Properties of Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8 Nanocrystalline Soft Magnetic Alloy[J]. Acta Metallurgica Sinica, 2026, 62(6): 1128-1136 DOI:10.11900/0412.1961.2024.00400

第三代半导体的发展促进了电子器件的高频化、高效化和小型化[1],这要求其中的软磁材料在具有高饱和磁通密度(Bs)和低矫顽力(Hc)的同时,还要具备优异的高频软磁性能。与高频铁心损耗(单位质量铁心损耗(Pcm)或单位体积铁心损耗(Pcv))较高的硅钢、Bs较低的铁氧体以及磁致伸缩系数较高的非晶态软磁合金相比,铁基纳米晶软磁合金因其独特的非晶+ α-Fe纳米晶双相结构而兼具高Bs、高有效磁导率(μe)以及低HcPcm等优异的软磁性能,在10~100 kHz频率范围内具有广阔的应用前景[2~8]

1988年,Yoshizawa等[9]首次开发出Fe-Si-B-Cu-Nb (Finemet)系纳米晶软磁合金,其出色的综合软磁性能引起广泛关注,加之其生产工艺性能好,迅速实现了商业化[10]。随后,研究人员又相继开发出了Fe-(Zr/Nb/Hf)-B (Nanoperm)[11]、(Fe, Co)-(Zr/Hf)-B-Cu (Hitperm)[12]和Fe-Si-B-P-Cu (Nanomet)[13]等典型纳米晶软磁合金体系。近年来,一系列新型具有高Bs的纳米晶合金也相继被研发出来,如Fe75.5Co0.5-Mo0.5Cu1Nb1.5Si13B8[14]和Fe85.5B10Si2P2C0.5[15]等。然而,Nanoperm和Hitperm合金中的Zr、Hf易氧化,难以在大气条件下制备;Nanomet合金需要在高升温速率下进行热处理,才能保证良好的软磁性,对热处理设备要求高,因此,这些纳米晶合金目前尚无法实现大规模工业化生产。为满足器件对软磁材料高频性能的更高要求,科研人员尝试通过优化合金成分和调控热处理工艺等手段进一步提高商用Finemet系纳米晶合金的高频软磁性能。Zhou等[14]通过在Fe76.5Si13B8Cu1Nb1.5纳米晶合金中添加Co和Mo元素,使其在100 kHz下的μe提高了44%。Mao等[16,17]采用1% (原子分数,下同)的Gd或Y元素替换Fe73.5Si13.5B9-Cu1Nb3纳米晶合金中的Fe,在提升其μe的同时,还改善了软磁性能的高温稳定性。Lu等[18]采用2%的V元素替换Fe73.5Si13.5B9Cu1Nb3纳米晶合金中的Nb,使其在0.5 T、20 kHz下的Pcv降低了33%。Fu等[19]通过磁场热处理将Fe73.5Si15.5B7Cu1Nb3纳米晶合金在100 kHz的μe提高3倍以上。Fan等[20]在热处理时施加410 MPa张应力,使Fe73.5Si13.5B9Cu1Nb3纳米晶合金的高频μe得到显著提升。He等[21]通过对Fe76Cu1Si14B6Nb3纳米晶铁心进行横向磁场退火,显著降低了其Pcm。当然,成分调控需要综合考虑非晶形成能力、软磁性能和生产工艺性之间的相互制约。采用磁场/应力热处理工艺虽然能够改善软磁性能,但也会导致生产工艺复杂化和制备成本增加。

随着合金带材制备技术的发展,降低带材厚度以提高纳米晶合金高频磁性能正受到越来越多的关注。Lee等[22]研究表明,当频率低于100 kHz时,厚度为20 μm的Fe83B9Nb7Cu1纳米晶带材的μe高于厚度为7 μm的纳米晶;但当频率高于100 kHz时,厚度为7 μm的薄带材的μe更高。Xu等[23]研究同样表明,当频率低于100 kHz时,Fe82B10Nb7Cu1纳米晶合金厚带材的μe高于薄带材,在频率高于100 kHz时发生反转。Jiang等[24]则发现,Fe73.5Si15.5B7Cu1Nb3纳米晶薄带材在1 kHz~1 MHz频率范围内始终具有比厚带材更高的μe。Lee等[22]发现,在0.2 T、100 kHz条件下,Fe83B9Nb7Cu1纳米晶薄带材较厚带材具有更低的Pcm。李准等[25]和时红昊等[26]也都通过降低纳米晶带材厚度降低了Pcm。目前,尽管通过降低带材厚度来降低纳米晶合金的高频损耗已得到普遍认可,但是带材厚度对磁导率的影响规律尚无统一结论,带材厚度对纳米晶合金高频磁化行为的影响机制也有待进一步澄清。

本工作以Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8合金为研究对象,制备了厚度为15~23 µm的合金带材,系统研究了带材厚度对该合金的快淬态与热处理态组织结构、静态和高频磁性能以及磁畴结构的影响规律,通过构建带材厚度-磁畴结构-高频软磁性能间的关联,讨论了带材厚度影响纳米晶合金高频磁化行为的机制。

1 实验方法

按照合金名义成分(原子分数) Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8称重配料,所用Fe、Si、B、Cu和Nb原料纯度(质量分数)均不低于99.5%。采用非自耗真空电弧炉在Ar气气氛中熔炼母合金锭,反复熔炼4遍以保证成分均匀,质量损失不超过0.2%。采用单辊甩带法制备宽度为1.5 mm的快淬合金带材,通过调整铜辊转速改变带材厚度(t = 15、19、23 µm,误差±1 µm),分别标记为T15、T19和T23。通过螺旋测微器进行多点测量以确认带材厚度(见补充材料图S1)。将快淬带材缠绕成内径为9 mm、外径为11 mm的环形铁心。将带材及铁心样品真空封装在石英管中,使用箱式马弗炉在783~883 K范围内间隔20 K等温退火60 min,随后水淬获得纳米晶合金。采用TA SDT650差式扫描量热仪(DSC)分析快淬合金带材的热性能。采用D8 Focus X射线衍射仪(XRD,CuKα)对带材进行物相分析,并根据Scherrer公式估算α-Fe的平均晶粒尺寸(Dα-Fe)。采用JEM-2100F透射电子显微镜(TEM)表征带材微观组织并统计α-Fe晶粒尺寸分布,利用正态分布函数拟合获得Dα-Fe和尺寸分布标准差。分别使用MATS-2010SD直流B-H回线仪和7404S振动样品磁强计(VSM)测试样品的HcBs。采用Keysight E4990A阻抗分析仪测试样品在1~104 kHz频率下的μe。使用SY-8218交流B-H分析仪测试样品在最大磁感应强度(Bm)为0.2 T、频率为10~500 kHz下的Pcm。使用JK2516A直流低电阻测试仪测试样品的室温电阻率(R)。采用em-Kerr-highres磁光Kerr显微镜(MOKE)表征样品的准静态磁畴结构。利用Archimedes法测定合金的密度(ρ),所用溶液为邻苯二甲酸二乙酯,并以此进行磁性能单位换算。

2 实验结果

首先表征了不同厚度Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8快淬合金带材的结构和热性能。图1a为T15、T19和T23快淬带材自由面的XRD谱。所有XRD谱均呈现代表非晶态的典型漫散射峰,表明带材中均没有明显的晶体相析出。图1b为对应合金带材的DSC曲线。所有DSC曲线均由多个放热峰组成,其中第一峰与α-Fe相的生成有关,而其余峰对应Fe-B相及其他相的生成[27,28]。3种带材具有相同的热性能,第一晶化峰起始温度(Tx1)均为785 K,第二晶化峰起始温度(Tx2)均为968 K。

图1

图1   不同厚度Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8快淬合金带材的XRD谱和差式扫描量热(DSC)曲线

Fig.1   XRD patterns (a) and DSC curves (b) of melt-spun Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8 alloy ribbons with different thicknesses (t—ribbon thickness, Tx1onset temperature of the first crystallization peak, Tx2onset temperature of the second crystallization peak)


采用TEM进一步表征了快淬合金带材的微结构。以最厚的T23带材为例,其TEM明场像中没有明显衬度变化,相应的选区电子衍射(SAED)花样呈晕环状(图2a),高分辨TEM (HRTEM)像中也未观察到任何有序结构(图2b),表明快淬合金中无晶体相析出,为单一非晶态结构。结合XRD、DSC和TEM结果可知,所有快淬合金带材均为完全非晶态结构。

图2

图2   厚度为23 µm的Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8快淬合金带材的TEM明场像、HRTEM像和选区电子衍射(SAED)花样

Fig.2   Bright-field TEM (a) and HRTEM (b) images of melt-spun Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8 alloy ribbon with a thickness of 23 μm (Inset in Fig.2a is the corresponding SAED pattern)


随后研究了Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8合金带材经热处理后的磁性能。由不同厚度合金带材的BsHc与退火温度(Ta)的关系(图3)可见,经783~863 K退火60 min后,各带材的Bs相较于快淬态均显著增加,维持在1.35~1.36 T (以ρ = 7.362 g/cm3换算),而经883 K退火后又呈现略微降低的趋势。随着Ta升高,各带材的Hc均呈现先降低后升高的变化趋势;经843 K退火60 min后,各合金带材均可获得最低的Hc,对应数值为0.5~0.6 A/m,无明显差异。不同厚度合金带材在经843 K退火后均获得了最优的综合静态磁性能,即兼具较高的Bs与较低的Hc,并且在该温度附近的一定波动范围内,带材的磁性能保持相对稳定。因此,确定843 K、60 min为最佳热处理工艺,后续的高频磁性能测试也以该工艺下处理的带材为主。各合金带材在该工艺下的BsHc具体数值见表1

图3

图3   不同厚度Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8合金带材的磁通密度(Bs)和矫顽力(Hc)与退火温度(Ta)的关系

Fig.3   Variations in saturation magnetic flux density (Bs) (a) and coercivity (Hc) (b) of Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8 alloy ribbons with different thicknesses as a function of annealing temperature (Ta)


表1   不同厚度Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8纳米晶带材的α-Fe平均晶粒尺寸和磁性能参数

Table 1  Average α-Fe grain size and magnetic properties of Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8 nanocrystalline alloys with different thicknesses

Alloy

t

µm

Dα-Fe

nm

Bs

T

Hc

A·m-1

μePcm / (W·kg-1)
100 kHz1 MHz0.2 T, 100 kHz0.2 T, 500 kHz
T151511.01.360.617000520067811
T191911.61.360.5165004100811017
T232311.41.350.51400029001081396

Note:Dα-Fe—average α-Fe grain size, μe—effective permeability, Pcm—core loss per unit mass

新窗口打开| 下载CSV


经843 K退火的各合金带材的μe与频率(f)的关系如图4a所示。各带材的μe在1~60 kHz频率下保持稳定,且数值无明显差异,均维持在22000左右,但随频率继续升高,其μe开始逐渐下降。T15、T19和T23带材的μe开始显著下降时的频率分别为60、150和300 kHz,表明薄带材的μe具有更好的频率稳定性,在60 kHz以上时,薄带材具有高的μe。T15带材在100 kHz和1 MHz下的μe分别为17000和5200,远高于T23带材的14000和2900。图4b为各合金带材的Pcm随频率的变化曲线。尽管各带材的Pcm均随频率的升高而呈现上升趋势,但是在相同频率下,薄带材的Pcm更低,且该现象随频率升高更加显著。当Bm为0.2 T、频率为100 kHz时,T15带材的Pcm为67 W/kg,分别比T19和T23带材降低了17.3%和38.0%;在频率为500 kHz时,T15带材的Pcm为811 W/kg,相比T19和T23带材降低幅度可达20.3%和41.9%。各带材的μePcm的具体数值见表1

图4

图4   843 K退火60 min后不同厚度Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8合金带材的有效磁导率(μe)和单位质量铁心损耗(Pcm)与频率的关系

Fig.4   Frequency (f) dependences of μe (The arrows denote the frequencies for μe starting to decline) (a) and Pcm (Inset shows the partial enlarged view of 10-100 kHz) (b) of Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8 alloy ribbons with different thicknesses after annealing at 843 K for 60 min


图5为不同厚度合金带材经843 K退火60 min后的XRD谱和TEM分析结果。如图5a所示,各退火带材的XRD谱均在45°和65°附近出现衍射峰,分别对应α-Fe相的(110)和(200)晶面。利用Scherrer公式估算得到T15、T19和T23带材的Dα-Fe分别为11.0、11.6和11.4 nm (见表1)。图5b~d为不同厚度合金带材退火的TEM明场像、相应的SAED花样和晶粒尺寸分布。3种合金带材的非晶基体中都均匀析出了α-Fe纳米晶粒,形成了典型的非晶+纳米晶双相结构。根据TEM结果统计晶粒尺寸可以得到,T15、T19和T23带材的Dα-Fe分别为11.3、11.5和11.0 nm (与XRD估算结果相近),晶粒尺寸分布标准差分别为2.9、2.5和2.7。结合XRD和TEM结果可知,T15、T19和T23带材经热处理后获得了基本一致的纳米晶组织结构。

图5

图5   843 K退火60 min后不同厚度Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8合金带材的XRD谱和TEM分析

Fig.5   XRD patterns (a) and bright-field TEM images (Insets are SAED patterns and grain size distributions with normal fitting. N—normal distribution) (b-d) of Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8 alloy ribbons with different thicknesses after annealing at 843 K for 60 min

(b) t = 15 µm (c) t = 19 µm (d) t = 23 µm


3 分析与讨论

纳米晶合金优异的软磁性能源于其非晶+纳米晶双相组织结构。根据Herzer[29]提出的随机各向异性模型,对于铁基纳米晶合金,当Dα-Fe小于40 nm时,晶粒间的铁磁交换耦合作用会显著降低磁晶各向异性,从而实现低的Hc,并且通常HcDα-Fe6成正比。在本工作中,不同厚度的纳米晶合金带材具有相近的组织结构,Dα-Fe为11.0~11.6 nm,因此所有带材的Hc均相近且较低,仅为0.5~0.6 A/m。相比Finemet典型成分Fe73.5Si13.5B9Cu1Nb3 (Bs约为1.24 T),本工作中的Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8合金中Fe含量更多、Nb含量更少,因此,Nb对合金Bs的负面影响减弱,故其Bs (1.35~1.36 T)更高。

为了进一步分析薄带材具有低Pcm的原因,根据Bertotti损耗分离理论[30]将损耗分为3部分:

Pt=Ph+Pec+Pex

式中,Pt为总损耗,即PcmPh为磁滞损耗;Pec为涡流损耗;Pex为剩余损耗。根据Steinmetz公式,式(1)可进一步写为[31]

Pt=ChBmαf+CecBm2f2+CexBm1.5f1.5

式中,α为Steinmetz系数;ChCecCex分别为磁滞损耗、涡流损耗和剩余损耗的系数。基于式(2)对测试得到的Pcm随频率的变化曲线进行非线性曲线拟合,拟合时以f为拟合函数自变量,Pt为因变量,由于本实验中Bm固定为0.2 T,故将ChBmαCecBm2CexBm1.5分别设为参数abc,经非线性曲线拟合后可得到abc,进而可得到不同频率下的各项损耗(具体数值见补充材料表S1)。以拟合得到的T19带材各频率下的损耗分离结果(图6a)为例,各损耗均呈现随频率升高而增加的趋势。分析各损耗的占比(图6b)可知,在10~500 kHz范围内,Ph占比较小,低于10%,且随频率上升而逐渐降低,特别是在100 kHz以上基本可以忽略;Pec占比则随频率上升而逐渐增加,在100 kHz以上时超过20%;尽管Pex占比随频率的上升而逐渐降低,但始终在50%以上。考虑Ph在高频下占比极低,这里仅对比不同厚度带材的PecPex。如图7所示,PecPex均随带材厚度的降低而降低,且降低幅度随频率的上升而逐渐增加。当Bm为0.2 T、频率为100 kHz时,T15带材的Pec比T23带材降低58.2%,Pex降低34.5%;在频率为500 kHz时,T15带材的PecPex相比T23带材分别降低58.0%和29.2%。可见,薄带材高频Pcm的降低主要来源于PecPex降低的协同贡献。

图6

图6   厚度为19 μm的Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8纳米晶带材的磁滞损耗(Ph)、涡流损耗(Pec)和剩余损耗(Pex)及各损耗占比(P / Pt)与频率的关系

Fig.6   Frequency dependences of hysteresis loss (Ph), Eddy current loss (Pec), and excess loss (Pex) (Inset shows the partial enlarged view of 10-100 kHz) (a) and loss / total loss (P / Pt) (b) of Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8 nanocrystalline ribbons with a thickness of 19 μm


图7

图7   不同厚度Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8纳米晶带材的PecPex与频率的关系

Fig.7   Frequency dependences of Pec (a) and Pex (b) of Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8 nanocrystalline ribbons with different thicknesses (Insets show the partial enlarged views of 10-100 kHz)


Pec是材料内部感应电流引起的损耗,可通过以下公式计算[32]

Pec=πtfBm26Rρ

测得不同厚度纳米晶合金带材的R均为(118 ± 4) × 10-8 Ω·m,ρ为7.362 × 103 kg/m3,这与与其相似的纳米晶组织结构相符。根据式(3)计算得到的Pec与由式(2)拟合的结果基本一致,表明损耗分离结果准确。由式(3)可知,在Rρ不变的情况下,降低带材厚度必然显著降低高频下的Pec

为了明确带材厚度引起的纳米晶带材高频Pex的差异,观察了不同厚度带材的磁畴结构。如图8所示,深浅不同的区域代表不同磁矩方向的磁畴,随着外磁场的增加,磁矩方向与外磁场方向接近的磁畴增大,当外磁场约为零时,得到合金在退磁状态的磁畴组态。由图8可知,随着带材厚度的降低,磁畴逐渐变成规则的长条状,且薄带材的磁畴宽度更小,磁畴和畴壁数量更多。T23、T19和T15带材在退磁状态下的磁畴宽度分别为(35 ± 5)、(21 ± 3)和(14 ± 2) µm。另外,T19和T15带材在磁化过程中伴随着畴壁上锯齿状突起的出现和消失(图8b2~b4c2~c4),对应于磁畴内部亚磁畴的旋转,这表明薄带材在磁化过程中可以更容易地诱发磁畴旋转。一方面,Pex来源于畴壁移动产生的局部涡流,与畴壁移动距离和移动速率有关[24,33]。T23带材的磁畴宽度大,磁化时畴壁移动距离长、速率快,故产生的局部涡流更大;T15带材磁畴均匀且宽度窄,磁化时畴壁移动距离短且速率慢,可避免较大局部涡流的产生。另一方面,Pex与磁后效有关,源于磁化过程中畴壁位移和/或磁畴旋转的时间效应。高频下畴壁来不及进行长距离的移动,而磁畴旋转具有更短的弛豫时间[14],故磁化主要以磁畴旋转的方式进行[23],并且高频下磁畴会进一步分裂成斑块状磁畴[34,35]。薄带材在准静态磁化过程中已经表现出了一定的磁畴旋转趋势,并且其窄的磁畴也容易发生分裂和畴形核,有利于高频下的磁畴旋转。这两方面均有利于薄带材高频Pex的降低。同样,薄带材在高频(> 60 kHz)下展现出更高的µe,这也归因于其更窄的磁畴结构和亚磁畴的存在。这种磁畴在高频下更容易分化为斑块畴,有利于磁畴旋转[34,35],同时多磁畴的均匀协同磁化提高了磁化响应速率,这些因素共同促进了高频下磁化的进行,因此薄带材的高频磁导率远高于厚带材。

图8

图8   不同厚度Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8纳米晶带材磁畴随变化磁场的演变

Fig.8   Evolutions of magnetic domain structures of Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8 nanocrystalline ribbons with different thicknesses under varying magnetic fields (a1-a5) t = 23 µm (b1-b5) t = 19 µm (c1-c5) t = 15 µm


4 结论

(1) 厚度为15~23 µm的Fe75.2Si13B8Cu1Nb2.8急冷合金带材均为完全非晶态结构。经843 K等温退火60 min后,所有带材均形成了一致的微细、均匀非晶+ α-Fe纳米晶双相组织,Dα-Fe在11.0~11.6 nm范围内。

(2) 不同厚度纳米晶合金带材的静态磁性能无明显差异,其BsHc分别为1.35~1.36 T和0.5~0.6 A/m。当频率低于60 kHz时,所有纳米晶带材的μe均稳定在22000;在60 kHz以上时,薄带材展现出更好的频率稳定性,且在相同频率下其μe更高。T15带材在100 kHz和1 MHz的μe分别为17000和5200,远高于T23带材的14000和2900。薄带材还具有较低的高频损耗,在0.2 T、100 kHz和0.2 T、500 kHz条件下,T15带材的Pcm分别为67和811 W/kg,较T23带材分别降低38.0%和41.9%。

(3) 薄带材较低的高频Pcm主要归因于PecPex的降低。减小带材厚度使得纳米晶合金的磁畴结构更加细化,有助于高频下磁畴旋转、缩短磁化弛豫时间、提升磁化响应速率,从而提高了高频磁导率并降低了Pex

文中补充材料可通过以下网址查看:https://www.ams.org.cn/CN/10.11900/0412.1961.2024.00400

参考文献

Zhou J F, You J H, Qiu K Q.

Advances in Fe-based amorphous/nanocrystalline alloys

[J]. J. Appl. Phys., 2022, 132: 040702

[本文引用: 1]

Han M H, Sun C, Meng Y, et al.

Effect of miscible and immiscible element microalloying on crystallization behavior and soft magnetic properties of Fe-P-C-B amorphous alloy

[J]. J. Non-Cryst. Solids, 2023, 611: 122352

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Shi L X, Yao K F.

Composition design for Fe-based soft magnetic amorphous and nanocrystalline alloys with high Fe content

[J]. Mater. Des., 2020, 189: 108511

DOI      URL    

Luo Q, Li D H, Cai M J, et al.

Excellent magnetic softness-magnetization synergy and suppressed defect activation in soft magnetic amorphous alloys by magnetic field annealing

[J]. J. Mater. Sci. Technol., 2022, 116: 72

DOI     

Fe-based amorphous alloys with high saturation magnetic flux density (Bs) are increasingly attractive from both scientific and technological points of view, however, they usually suffer from the trade-off between magnetization and softness. In this work, we explore the soft magnetic properties (SMPs), magnetic and atomic structures, and defect activation during creep deformation of as-quenched and annealed Fe82.65-xCoxSi2B14Cu1.35 (x = 0-20) amorphous alloys (AAs). Improved magnetic softness-magnetization synergy has been realized in all these alloys by field annealing. Particularly, superb SMPs with super-high Bs of 1.86 T, low coercivity of 1.2 A/m and high effective permeability of 16300 are obtained in the Fe66.65Co16Si2B14Cu1.35 AA. The locally regularized arrangement of domains, homogenized structure with less structural/magnetic defects and suppressed crystal-like ordering by field annealing contribute synergistically to the superb SMPs. Besides, the relaxation time spectra obtained from creep deformation indicate less liquid-like and solid-like defects activated in the field-annealed AA, which is correlated with the structural homogenization and superb SMPs. This work provides new and comprehensive insight into the interplay among external field, heterogeneous structure, SMPs and defect activation of Fe-based AAs, and offers a promising pathway for softening amorphous alloys with high Bs.

Pang L L, Inoue A, Zanaeva E N, et al.

Nanocrystallization, good soft magnetic properties and ultrahigh mechanical strength for Fe82-85B13-16Si1Cu1 amorphous alloys

[J]. J. Alloys Compd., 2019, 785: 25

DOI      URL    

Herzer G.

Modern soft magnets: Amorphous and nanocrystalline materials

[J]. Acta Mater., 2013, 61: 718

DOI      URL    

Zhu C J, Li Y H, Zhu Z W, et al.

Regulation of structure and magnetic properties of Fe98.5-xBxCu1.5 nanocrystalline alloys based on B content

[J]. Acta Metall. Sin., 2025, 61: 1174

朱春健, 李艳辉, 朱正旺 .

B含量调控Fe98.5-xBxCu1.5纳米晶合金组织结构和磁性能

[J]. 金属学报, 2025, 61: 1174

DOI     

为研发具有良好软磁性和工艺性的高饱和磁感应强度(Bs) 铁基纳米晶合金,本工作以高Fe含量的Fe-B-Cu合金体系为对象,研究了B含量对Fe98.5 - x B x Cu1.5 (x = 12~18,原子分数,%)系快淬合金带材的微结构、结晶化组织和磁性能的影响,分析了B含量-快淬微结构-结晶化组织-磁性能间的关联。结果表明,快淬合金均为非晶基体中分布着纳米尺度α-Fe晶粒(预存α-Fe晶)的结构;随x由12增加至18,非晶基体中预存α-Fe晶的数密度和晶粒尺寸逐渐降低,结构转变为近非晶态。经低升温速率热处理后,x = 12~17时合金均为非晶/α-Fe纳米晶双相结构,而x = 18时合金形成了非晶/α-Fe/Fe3B纳米复相组织结构;x = 13~16时合金具有微细的纳米晶组织和较好的软磁性能,α-Fe相的平均晶粒尺寸(D¯α-Fe)、Bs和矫顽力(Hc)分别在15.8~16.3 nm、1.80~1.91 T和18.9~22.7 A/m的范围内,其中x = 15时合金的D¯α-Fe、Bs和Hc分别为16.0 nm、1.86 T和18.9 A/m。基于合金热处理前后的组织结构演化,提出了不同B含量快淬合金的结晶化模型,阐明了快淬合金非晶基体中高数密度的细小预存α-Fe晶粒间以及与热处理结晶化新生α-Fe晶粒间的强竞争生长效应,导致均匀、微细纳米晶组织形成的机制。

Guo S S, Li Y H, Zhang Y B, et al.

Reduction of high-frequency core loss of a Fe77.2Si11B8.5Cu0.8Nb2.5 soft magnetic nanocrystalline alloy by minor alloying

[J]. Acta Metall. Sin. (Engl. Lett.), 2024, 37: 1984

DOI      [本文引用: 1]

Yoshizawa Y, Oguma S, Yamauchi K.

New Fe-based soft magnetic alloys composed of ultrafine grain structure

[J]. J. Appl. Phys., 1988, 64: 6044

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

The magnetic properties of Fe-Si-B-M (M: additives) alloys prepared by annealing amorphous alloys made by the single roller method over their crystallization temperature have been investigated for development of new Fe-based soft magnetic alloys. Excellent soft magnetic properties were obtained by adding the two elements Cu and Nb to Fe-Si-B alloys. It was found that these new alloys, called ‘‘FINEMET,’’ have an ultrafine grain structure composed of bcc Fe solid solution. They are suitable for many kinds of magnetic components such as saturable reactors, choke coils, and transformers, because they have superior soft magnetic properties and a high saturation flux density, and because different types of B-H hysteresis loops are obtained by magnetic field annealing.

Ding J L, Xu H J, Shi Z G, et al.

Effect of primary α-Fe on soft magnetic properties of FeCuNbSiB amorphous/nanocrystalline alloy

[J]. J. Non-Cryst. Solids, 2021, 571: 121079

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Makino A, Inoue A, Masumoto T.

Soft magnetic properties of nanocrystalline Fe-M-B (M = Zr, Hf, Nb) alloys with high magnetization

[J]. Nanostruct. Mater., 1995, 6: 985

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Willard M A, Laughlin D E, Mchenry M E, et al.

Structure and magnetic properties of (Fe0.5Co0.5)88Zr7B4Cu1 nanocrystalline alloys

[J]. J. Appl. Phys., 1998, 84: 6773

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

The development of Fe73.5Si13.5B9Nb3Cu1 (FINEMET) by Yoshizawa et al. and Fe88Zr7B4Cu1 (NANOPERM) by Inoue et al. have shown that nanocrystalline microstructures can play an important role in the production of materials with outstanding soft magnetic properties. The FINEMET and NANOPERM materials rely on nanocrystalline α-Fe3Si and α-Fe, respectively, for their soft magnetic properties. The magnetic properties of a new class of nanocrystalline magnets are described herein. These alloys with a composition of (Fe,Co)–M–B–Cu (where M=Zr and Hf) are based on the α- and α′-FeCo phases, have been named HITPERM magnets, and offer large magnetic inductions to elevated temperatures. This report focuses on thermomagnetic properties, alternating current (ac) magnetic response, and unambiguous evidence of α′-FeCo as the nanocrystalline ferromagnetic phase, as supported by synchrotron x-ray diffraction. Synchrotron data have distinguished between the HITPERM alloy, with nanocrystallites having a B2 structure from the FINEMET alloys, with the D03 structure, and NANOPERM alloys, with the A2 structure. Thermomagnetic data shows high magnetization to persist to the α→γ phase transformation at 980 °C. The room temperature ac permeability has been found to maintain a high value of 1800 up to a frequency of ∼2 kHz. The room temperature core loss has also been shown to be competitive with that of commercial high temperature alloys with a value of 1 W/g at BS=10 kG and f=1 kHz.

Makino A.

Nanocrystalline soft magnetic Fe-Si-B-P-Cu alloys with high B of 1.8-1.9 T contributable to energy saving

[J]. IEEE Trans. Magn., 2012, 48: 1331

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Zhou J, Li X S, Hou X B, et al.

Ultrahigh permeability at high frequencies via a magnetic-heterogeneous nanocrystallization mechanism in an iron-based amorphous alloy

[J]. Adv. Mater., 2023, 35: 2304490

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 3]

Li H, Wang A D, Liu T, et al.

Design of Fe-based nanocrystalline alloys with superior magnetization and manufacturability

[J]. Mater. Today, 2021, 42: 49

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Mao Y C, Zhu Z H, Zhao H.

Microstructures and soft magnetic properties of Fe73.5-xCu1Nb3Si13.5B9Gdx (x = 0-1.5) alloys

[J]. Materials, 2022, 15: 2973

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

In this experiment, the rare earth Gd element was added to Finemet alloy to observe the microstructure and soft magnetic properties. The experimental results showed that the samples with the addition of 0.5% Gd and 1.0% Gd can be quenched and cast normally, and the MS of Fe73Cu1Nb3Si13.5B9Gd0.5 alloy was 10.41% higher than that of Finemet. After annealing, crystal grains of about 10 nm were formed. The μi and μm values of Fe73Cu1Nb3Si13.5B9Gd0.5 alloy were 25.51% and 22.23% higher, respectively, and the coercivity HC was reduced by 12.19% compared to Finemet. At 1 kHz, the μe value of Fe73Cu1Nb3Si13.5B9Gd0.5 alloy at room temperature was 14.57% higher than that of Finemet, while the μe reached 162.34 k and 142.42 k at 90 °C and 150 °C (24% and 29.51% higher, respectively). The Fe72.5Cu1Nb3Si13.5B9Gd1.0 alloy had the best performance at 100 kHz, with higher μe values than Finemet across the ambient temperature range of 30 °C to 150 °C. After tension annealing, the μe values of Fe72.5Cu1Nb3Si13.5B9Gd1.0 alloy were 20–30% higher than those of Finemet.

Mao Y C, Zhu Z H, Zhao H.

Microstructures and soft magnetic properties of Fe73.5-xCu1Nb3Si13.5B9Yx (x = 0-1.5) alloys

[J]. Results Phys., 2022, 34: 105232

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Lu W, Yan B, Li Y, et al.

Structure and soft magnetic properties of V-doped finemet-type alloys

[J]. J. Alloys Compd., 2008, 454: L10

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Fu P X, Shi J L, Shi R C, et al.

Effect of low magnetic field heat treatment process on grain sizes and soft magnetic properties of finemet cores

[J]. Mater. Today Commun., 2023, 36: 106685

[本文引用: 1]

Fan X Z, Wang Z, Fang Z, et al.

Orientation dependence of the nanocrystallization and magnetic behavior during annealing of the finemet alloy

[J]. J. Non-Cryst. Solids, 2024, 625: 122736

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

He A N, Li J W, Wang M K, et al.

Microstructure, magnetic domain and dynamic loss of surface-textured Fe-based nanocrystalline alloy

[J]. J. Mater. Sci. Technol., 2022, 120: 1

DOI      [本文引用: 1]

Heterogeneous coarse surface crystallites induced in the industrial Fe-rich nanocrystalline alloy is an obstacle for high-frequency and high-power commercial applications. Herein, the phase, crystal orientation, nanostructure and magnetic domain evolution of the surface-crystallized Fe-rich alloy were systematically investigated. Microstructure and inverse pole figures analysis confirms that the DO3 ordered dendritic-crystallites bear <001>-oriented fiber texture before and after annealing at the free surface, while ultrafine nanocrystals are randomly oriented in the interior and wheel surface after annealing. As compared to zero magnetic-field-annealing, the transverse magnetic-field-annealing induces weakly oriented fiber texture and relatively uniform dendritic-crystallites at the surface, and uniform anisotropy in the interior and surface, which promotes smooth wall motion at the surface and magnetization rotation in the interior. This synergetic effect reduces the excess loss and leads reduction in dynamic loss at 1.0 T and 10 kHz by 36%.

Lee J S, Kim K Y, Noh T H, et al.

The magnetic properties of ultrathin FeBNbCu nanocrystalline alloy

[J]. IEEE Trans. Magn., 1995, 31: 3901

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 2]

Xu F, Qin W, Peng K, et al.

The mechanism of magnetic relaxation in Fe-based nanocrystalline alloy ribbons investigated by permeability spectroscopy

[J]. Mater. Res. Bull., 2004, 39: 1029

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 2]

Jiang M, Cai M, Zhou J, et al.

Superior high-frequency performances of Fe-based soft-magnetic nanocrystalline alloys

[J]. Mater. Today Nano, 2023, 22: 100307

[本文引用: 2]

Li Z, Li D R, Li G M, et al.

Effect of thickness of FeCuNbSiB ribbon on magnetic properties of tape wounded cores

[J]. Met. Funct. Mater., 2011, 18(6): 1

[本文引用: 1]

李 准, 李德仁, 李广敏 .

带厚对FeCuNbSiB纳米晶铁芯性能的影响

[J]. 金属功能材料, 2011, 18(6): 1

[本文引用: 1]

Shi H H, Wang L J, Song C Y.

Effect of ribbon thickness on soft magnetic properties of amorphous and nanocrystalline tape wounded cores

[J]. Hot Work. Technol., 2014, 43(22): 122

[本文引用: 1]

时红昊, 王立军, 宋翀旸.

带厚对非晶纳米晶铁芯软磁性能的影响

[J]. 热加工工艺, 2014, 43(22): 122

[本文引用: 1]

Wang Y F, Xu J, Liu Y J, et al.

Microstructure evolution, magnetic properties and frequency characteristics of Si-rich FeSiBCuNb soft magnetic alloy induced by annealing treatment

[J]. Mater. Charact., 2022, 187: 111830

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Cao Y, Yang F Y, Li J W, et al.

High-frequency magnetic characteristics and operating thermal stability of industrialized Fe76Si13B8Nb2-Cu1 nanocrystalline alloy

[J]. J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 2021, 526: 167691

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Herzer G.

Grain size dependence of coercivity and permeability in nanocrystalline ferromagnets

[J]. IEEE Trans. Magn., 1990, 26: 1397

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Bertotti G.

General properties of power losses in soft ferromagnetic materials

[J]. IEEE Trans. Magn., 1988, 24: 621

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Zhang L, Wang Y F, Zou L, et al.

Effect of grain size on magnetic loss of nanocrystalline alloy under high-frequency non-sinusoidal excitation

[J]. IEEE Trans. Magn., 2023, 59: 2800411

[本文引用: 1]

Parsons R, Zang B, Onodera K, et al.

Core loss of ultra-rapidly annealed Fe-rich nanocrystalline soft magnetic alloys

[J]. J. Magn. Magn. Mater., 2019, 476: 142

DOI      [本文引用: 1]

Ultra-rapidly annealed (heating rate > 10(4) K/s, annealing time < 1 s) Fe-rich nanocrystalline soft magnetic materials with a nominal composition of Fe100-xBx and Fe87-yB13My where x = 12, 13, 14, y = 1, 2 and M = Cu, Ni (HiB-Nanoperm) have recently been demonstrated with a saturation magnetic polarization (J(s)) up to 1.92 T and a low coercivity (H-c) of less than 8 A/m. In this study the AC core loss (P-cm) is estimated for HiB-Nanoperm at 50, 400 and 1000 Hz and is compared with existing amorphous, nanocrystalline and conventionally crystalline (Fe-Si) materials. The P-cm of HiB-Nanoperm at 1.5 T, 50 Hz is demonstrated to be 5-15% that of Fe-3 wt% Si. In specific, Fe86B13Cu1 displays losses that are 30% that of Fe-6.5 wt% Si steel while also possessing a 5% larger J(s). For maximum magnetic polarization (J(m)) values greater than 1.5 T this same composition also exhibits some of the lowest core losses seen from all Fe-based nanocrystalline alloys across the frequencies tested in this study. Core loss separation and an estimation of the anomaly factor (eta) for selected HiB-Nanoperm alloys is also undertaken and compared with a Fe-based amorphous alloy. The eta of HiB-Nanoperm is seen to be lower than that of Fe-based amorphous alloy and is also observed to be positively correlated with saturation magnetostriction. The low core loss of HiB-Nanoperm is attributed to a reduced anomalous loss which may be brought about by the moderate magnetostriction of this alloy.

Zhang R H, He A N, Xie L, et al.

Correlation between dynamic magnetization process and dynamic domains of high saturation induction FeSiBNbCuMo nanocrystalline alloy with dual anisotropies

[J]. J. Alloys Compd., 2022, 891: 161956

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Flohrer S, Schafer R, McCord J, et al.

Dynamic magnetization process of nanocrystalline tape wound cores with transverse field-induced anisotropy

[J]. Acta Mater., 2006, 54: 4693

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 2]

Flohrer S, Schäfer R, McCord J, et al.

Magnetization loss and domain refinement in nanocrystalline tape wound cores

[J]. Acta Mater., 2006, 54: 3253

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 2]

/