金属学报, 2026, 62(10): 1687-1701 DOI: 10.11900/0412.1961.2024.00311

研究论文

细观力学模拟双峰晶粒分布铜的异质变形诱导效应

李少杰1, 金剑锋,1,2, 田艳中1, 潘虎成1, 王明涛1, 秦高梧,1,2,3

1 东北大学 材料科学与工程学院 沈阳 110819

2 辽宁材料实验室 材料智能技术研究所 沈阳 110167

3 沈阳化工大学 战略材料与关键构件研究院 沈阳 110142

Micromechanics Modeling of the Hetero-Deformation Induced Strengthening and Strain Hardening Effect in Bimodal Structure Copper

LI Shaojie1, JIN Jianfeng,1,2, TIAN Yanzhong1, PAN Hucheng1, WANG Mingtao1, QIN Gaowu,1,2,3

1 School of Materials Science and Engineering, Northeastern University, Shenyang 110819, China

2 Institute of Materials Intelligent Technology, Liaoning Academy of Materials, Shenyang 110167, China

3 Institute for Strategic Materials and Components, Shenyang University of Chemical Technology, Shenyang 110142, China

通讯作者: 金剑锋,jinjf@atm.neu.edu.cn,主要从事计算材料学、颗粒增强复合材料力学性能方面的研究;秦高梧,qingw@smm.neu.edu.cn,主要从事计算材料学辅助高性能、新材料设计和制备方面的研究

收稿日期: 2024-09-03   修回日期: 2024-10-14  

基金资助: 国家重点研发计划项目(2023YFB3710900)

Corresponding authors: JIN Jianfeng, associate professor, Tel: 13194248493, E-mail:jinjf@atm.neu.edu.cn;QIN Gaowu, professor, Tel:(024)83691565, E-mail:qingw@smm.neu.edu.cn

Received: 2024-09-03   Revised: 2024-10-14  

Fund supported: National Key Research and Development Program of China(2023YFB3710900)

作者简介 About authors

李少杰,男,1995年生,博士生

摘要

双峰异质结构金属因其独特的异质变形诱导(HDI)强化和应变硬化效应,可具有强塑兼备的力学性能;然而HDI微观机制如何发挥作用尚不清晰。本工作基于Mori-Tanaka平均场方法,以双峰异构金属Cu为例(细晶230 nm和粗晶3 μm),构建了细观力学模型的框架,其中双峰结构由微米级粗晶作为粒子相、纳米级细晶作为基体相的异构基元构成;结合塑性应变梯度与位错密度演化理论,将塑性变形过程中产生的HDI效应以软域硬化、硬域软化和应力再协调三个阶段引入各相的本构关系中,定量评估HDI效应对双峰结构材料整体力学行为的影响。通过对比计算与实验结果,认为硬域中的前应力效应归因于前应力促使硬域内缠结位错的解缠而导致的软化与促使硬域内剪切带形成而导致的硬化的共同作用。通过与双峰结构铜的实验拉伸应力-应变曲线比较,验证了模型的有效性。结果表明,当硬域完全包裹软域时,前应力效应对双峰结构铜的综合力学性能起主要作用;随着软域体积分数的增加,双峰结构铜整体强度增加而拉伸塑性下降;当软域体积分数为25%~30%时,存在强塑匹配最佳值:双峰结构铜的抗拉强度417~420 MPa、延伸率28.2%~29.8%,相比均质细晶Cu,强度减低7%、拉伸塑性提升了10倍;相比均质粗晶Cu,强度提高约100%、拉伸塑性降低约50%。

关键词: 双峰结构; 细观力学; 塑性应变梯度理论; 异质变形诱导效应; 力学性能

Abstract

Owing to their unique hetero-deformation induced (HDI) strengthening and strain hardening effect, bimodal structure alloys can exhibit excellent strength-ductility synergy. However, the roles of the HDI mechanism remain incompletely understood. This study establishes a micromechanical model of the bimodal structure of pure Cu with 230 nm fine grains and 3 μm coarse grains as an example and estimates the HDI effects on the mechanical properties of Cu. This model is based on the Mori-Tanaka mean field method. The bimodal structure comprises a particulate inclusion phase of coarse grains (soft zone) and a hard matrix phase of fine grains (hard zone). Combining plastic strain gradient and dislocation theories, the HDI effect is proposed as a three-stage process of soft zone hardening, hard zone softening, and stress repartitioning, thereby providing quantitative assessments of the HDI effects on the overall mechanical behaviors of bimodal copper. Based on the experimental observations, the forward stress effect is considered to result from softening via the disentanglement and annihilation of entangled dislocations and from hardening caused by shear band formations. The model predictions favorably agree with the existing experimental data. The role of the forward stress effect in the mechanical response is apparently enhanced when the hard zone (230 nm grains) completely encloses the soft zone (3 μm grains). Moreover, increasing the volume fraction of the soft zone decreases the overall strength and reduces the ductility of Cu. At soft zone fractions of 25%-30%, the strength and ductility were optimally balanced with a tensile strength of 417-420 MPa and an elongation of 28.2%-29.8%. The ultimate tensile strength and elongation were 7% lower and 10-fold higher, respectively, than those of unimodal 230-nm-grained Cu and almost doubled and halved, respectively, from those of unimodal 3-μm-grained Cu.

Keywords: bimodal structure; micromechanics; strain gradient theory of plasticity; heterogeneous deformation-induced (HDI) effect; mechanical property

PDF (2980KB) 元数据 多维度评价 相关文章 导出 EndNote| Ris| Bibtex  收藏本文

本文引用格式

李少杰, 金剑锋, 田艳中, 潘虎成, 王明涛, 秦高梧. 细观力学模拟双峰晶粒分布铜的异质变形诱导效应[J]. 金属学报, 2026, 62(10): 1687-1701 DOI:10.11900/0412.1961.2024.00311

LI Shaojie, JIN Jianfeng, TIAN Yanzhong, PAN Hucheng, WANG Mingtao, QIN Gaowu. Micromechanics Modeling of the Hetero-Deformation Induced Strengthening and Strain Hardening Effect in Bimodal Structure Copper[J]. Acta Metallurgica Sinica, 2026, 62(10): 1687-1701 DOI:10.11900/0412.1961.2024.00311

异质结构材料因具有优异的强度与拉伸塑性的结合,成为目前材料领域中研究热点之一,其优异力学性能归因于异构组织带来的自协调机制,即异质变形诱导(hetero-deformation induced,HDI)强化(下文称HDI效应)与应变硬化效应[1,2]。双峰分布结构(bimodal structure)合金是异质结构材料的典型代表,从Tellkamp等[3]和Wang等[4]分别发现具有双峰分布结构的5083铝合金和Cu具有良好的强塑性至今,双峰结构已扩展到了铜[5,6]、镍[7,8]、铁[9]、铝[10~12]、镁[13~18]等合金体系。

在双峰结构中,将具有较高持续应变硬化能力的大尺寸粗晶构成的域称为软域(soft zone),而硬化较差的细晶域称为硬域(hard zone)。一般而言,双峰结构的软域可分为三类:(1) 单个大尺寸晶粒(微米级)构成的域[13,15,19];(2) 多个大尺寸晶粒团簇形成的球状域[4,20,21];(3) 多个大尺寸晶粒并排形成的条状域[22]。对于均质结构来说,随晶粒尺寸降低、晶界占比增加,整体变形稳定性下降[23],导致局部颈缩和开裂的概率提升,拉伸塑性恶化;而双峰结构能够改善这种晶粒尺寸下降而导致的拉伸塑性降低,避免宏观颈缩的过早发生,保证了材料的强度与拉伸塑性的协同作用[6,24,25]。对于双峰结构来说,一般同时包含微米晶与纳米晶的组合,相比于均质结构,双峰结构在变形过程中软域(微米晶)被分配更多的应变,使域界面产生更大的应变梯度,增加位错塞积数量,在软域内形成了更大的背应力场,提升了软域及整体的强度[26~28]。也有研究[29,30]认为,几何必需位错(geometrically necessary dislocation,GND)的存在增加了晶内位错密度、缩短了位错滑移的平均自由程,使得软域具有更高的应变硬化能力。背应力的存在使得硬域在界面处存在与之相等的平衡力,即硬域内形成的前应力可激活在均质结构中难以开启的滑移系,使硬域中容纳更多的应变,增加整体的均匀变形能力,提高了材料的拉伸塑性[27,31~34]。实验研究发现,前应力不仅可促进硬域中特征应变带的形成,提升容纳应变[35~37],也能促进动态回复的发生[2],导致硬域的软化。

研究[38~40]发现,多数双峰结构材料仍遵循着“强度-拉伸塑性”倒置关系,仅通过实验方法难以对双峰异构组织进行高效设计和开发。基于此,Zhu等[27]和Li等[28]构建了双峰结构的细观力学模型,研究了晶粒的几何特征对背应力和综合力学性能的影响。Huang等[41]和Wang等[30]将硬域与软域之间的异构界面影响区引入材料的塑性本构关系,结合有限元方法研究了软域的几何特征对异构界面影响区占比和HDI效应的影响,结果表明,界面影响区在异构材料中的占比显著影响其力学性能。虽然上述模型提供了一些HDI效应的微观机理及其与异构组织和力学性能的关系,但目前并未构建出异构组织强化通用模型,以评估前应力对HDI效应及其整体力学性能的影响。

本工作主要基于Mori-Tanaka平均场方法,结合塑性应变梯度理论,构建细观力学异构模型;以双峰分布结构金属Cu (下文简称为双峰结构铜)为例,其中微米晶(尺寸约3 μm)作为软域粒子相、纳米晶(尺寸约230 nm)为硬域基体相,定量评估HDI效应对双峰结构铜拉伸力学行为的影响,并阐明微观变形的相关机制,据此提出双峰结构铜强塑兼备的组织设计方案。这些结果可为研究兼具高强塑性铜合金的异构组织设计提供理论指导。

1 模型描述

1.1 双峰结构异构基元平均场模型的几何建模

在细观力学平均场模型中,组成相可分为基体相和夹杂相,基体相是连续的,夹杂相被嵌入到基体中。以双峰结构铜为例,硬域(细晶)作为基体,软域(粗晶)作为夹杂相。硬域基体的相关变量记为下标“(0)”,软域夹杂的相关变量记为下标“(1)”,整体的相关变量记为下标“H”;二阶张量表示为“ a ”或“aij ”形式,四阶张量表示为“ A ”或“Aijkl ”形式。

平均场所需的几何模型建模过程如图1所示。具体步骤如下。

图1

图1   双峰结构异构基元的几何建模

Fig.1   Geometric modelling of the basic structural units of bimodal structure

(a) SEM image for bimodal structure Cu

(b) schematic of grain boundary profile

(c) schematic of mean-field composite model based on spherical particulate phase simplification (GND—geometrically necessary dislocation; d(0)—grain size in hard zone, d(1)—grain size in soft zone, Γ(0)—average distance between the nearest neighbors of the soft zones, Γ(1)—soft zone size, h(1)—spacing between neighboring pileups in soft zone)


(1) 金属Cu部分再结晶的双峰组织如图1a所示。其中,再结晶长大的大尺寸晶粒所形成的区域为软域,其均匀分布在未再结晶的小尺寸晶粒构成的硬域基体中,构成双峰结构的异构基元;由于退火时间较短,软域含量较少,可视为硬域充分包围着软域,由此可将连续分布的硬域作为基体。

(2) 通过晶界轮廓提取,如图1b所示。其抽象的模型见图1c。其中,浅蓝色区为软域,由平均尺寸为d1的晶粒构成,其域尺寸定义为Γ1=n¯1d1,n¯1为平均粗晶数量;灰色部分为硬域基体,由平均尺寸为d0的晶粒构成,软域之间的最近邻平均距离定义为Γ0=n¯0d0,n¯0为所含细晶数量。

(3) 假设粗晶软域为球形,硬域和软域均设为各向同性,类似于其他分析[27,28,42],对应的双峰结构异构基元的最小基础单元示意图如图1c所示。

(4) 当球形软域均匀分布时,图1c展示的最小基础单元的尺寸为ΓH=2n¯1d1+n¯0d0,则软域的含量(f1)与域尺寸之间的关系如下:

f1=V1VH=443πΓ1 / 2322Γ0+Γ13=
2π6n¯1d1n¯1d1+n¯0d03

式中,V1为软域体积,VH为异构基元体积。

1.2 基于位错密度的均质结构材料的本构模型

根据经典塑性理论,应变(εij)分为弹性部分(εije)和塑性部分(εijp):

εij=εije+εijp

εije可根据线弹性关系与应力(σij)联系起来,即:

εije=12μσij'+σkk9κδij=12μIijkld+13κIijklhσkl=Mijklσkl

式中,μ=E21+v和κ=E31-2v分别为剪切模量和体模量(其中,E为Young's模量,v为Poisson比),δij为Kronecker张量,σkk为正应力,σij'=σij-13σkkδij为偏应力,Mijkl为柔度张量,Iijklh=13δijδkl和Iijkld=12δikδjl+δilδjk-23δijδkl分别为各向同性算子和偏斜算子。σij可写作如下形式:

σij=13σkkδij+σij'=κ-23μεkkδij+2μεij=Lijklεije

式中,Lijkl=2μIijkld+3κIijklh为刚度张量,εkk为正应变。

εijp与σij'通过Hencky流动理论[43,44]相关联,即:

εijp=32εpσeqσij'

式中,σeq=32σij'σij'为von Mises等效应力,εp为等效塑性应变。在塑性力学中,使应力维持在屈服面上的屈服准则F [45]为:

F=σeq-σf=0

式中,σf为流变应力。从材料角度,均匀结构铜中的位错是其塑性变形和应变硬化的主导因素[46,47]。由位错相互作用带来的各向同性硬化,可依据Taylor关系[47]进行评估。因而,均质结构铜的流变应力可写为:

σf=σ0+MαμbρS

式中,σ0为晶格摩擦阻力,M为Taylor因子,α为对微观结构敏感的Taylor常数[24,48],b为Burgers矢量模,ρS为晶内统计存储位错(statistically stored dislocation,SSD)密度。SSDs源于晶内位错的随机产生、缠结和湮灭,根据Kocks-Mecking-Estrin (KME)模型[24], ρS随着εp的演化规律遵循:

d ρSd εp=Mk*bΛ-k2ρS=Mk0bd+k1bρS-k2ρS

式中,k*为比例系数;Λ为SSDs滑移的平均自由程,与晶粒尺寸(d)和SSDs平均间距(1 / ρS)有关;k0和k1为唯象系数,反映位错相互作用导致的位错存储速率;k2为位错动态恢复速率因子。

1.3 双峰结构异构基元的Mori-Tanaka平均场模型框架

由于异构基元内部两域的强度与应变硬化能力不同,在变形过程中,各域中分配的应变并不相同。而混合定律无法准确描述材料内部复杂的应力/应变分布及各类变形机制[49],因此无法直接用于评估异构材料强度。本工作在Mori-Tanaka方案[50,51]的基础上,结合Weng[43]的割线方法,模拟异构基元的塑性(非线性)行为。割线模量方法是将塑性基体等效为伪线弹性等效材料的方法[52],即σ=Lε-εp=Lsε,Ls使二者保持相同的应力/应变响应,本文中上标‘s’表示割线处理状态,σ、ε、εp和L分别为σij、εij、εijp和Lijkl的张量形式,从而计算出异构基元的整体力学响应和两域之间的应变分配。

在产生均匀整体外加应力(σA)的均匀牵引力边界条件下,基体等效材料的整体应力(εA)与应变之间的关系为εA=L0s-1σA。此时,硬域和软域的平均应力的表达式如下,推导过程参见文献[43,53]。

σ0=B0σA-C0εp1
σ1=B1σA+C1εp1

式中,·为对应域的体积平均值。B0=I+f1S1s-IQ1L1-L0s,C0=f1L0sL1S1s-IQ1,B1=I-f0S1s-IQ1L1-L0s,C1=f0L0sL1·

S1s-IQ1。其中,I=Ih+Id为等同张量,Q1=L1-L0sf1I+f0S1s+L0s-1,S为Eshelby张量,Ss为由割线模量确定出的Eshelby张量。对于嵌入到各向同性硬域基体内的球形软域,其Eshelby张量为[53]:

S1s=α1sIh+β1sId

式中,α1s=1+v0s31-v0s,β1s=24-v0s151-v0s。根据式(9)~(11)整理得到两域的平均正应力和偏应力为:

σkk0=α1sκ1-κ0+κ0f1+f0α1sκ1-κ0+κ0σA,kk  
σkk1=κ1f1+f0α1sκ1-κ0+κ0σA,kk 
σij0'=β1sμ1-μ0s+μ0sf1+f0β1sμ1-μ0s+μ0sσA,ij'+
2f11-β1sμ1μ0sf1+f0β1sμ1-μ0s+μ0sε1,ijp
σij1'=μ1f1+f0β1sμ1-μ0s+μ0sσA,ij'-
2f01-β1sμ1μ0sf1+f0β1sμ1-μ0s+μ0sε1,ijp

式中,σA,kk=3κ0εA,kk和σA,ij'=2μ0sεA,ij'分别为外加正应力和偏应力,εA,kk和εA,ij'=εA,ij-13εA,kkδij分别为外加正应变和偏应变。

此时,两域应变的差值,即扰动应变(εD)为:

εD=ε1-ε0=L1-1σ1+
εp1-L0s-1σ0=
S1sQ1L1-L0sεA-L1εp1

将其写为正应变和偏应变形式分别为:

εkkD=-α1sκ1-κ0f1+f0α1sκ1-κ0+κ0εA,kk
εijD'=-β1sμ1-μ0sf1+f0β1sμ1-μ0s+μ0sεA,ij'+
β1sμ1f1+f0β1sμ1-μ0s+μ0sε1p

根据平均应变定理[54],异构基元整体的正应变和偏应变可表示为两域内应变的加权平均值,从而有:

εkkH=1-f1κ1-κ0f1+f0α1sκ1-κ0+κ0εA,kk
εijH'=1-f1μ1-μ0sf1+f0β1sμ1-μ0s+μ0sεA,ij'+
f1μ1f1+f0β1sμ1-μ0s+μ0sε1p

显然,对于均匀材料,各相以及整体的应力-应变关系都有σkk=3κεkk,σij'=2μεij'-εijp,与 式(3)或(4)等价。

Weng[43]对比了割线模量方法与纯弹性方法(即基体和夹杂都采用σij=Lijklεije=Lijklεij-εijp进行计算)对整体力学响应的评估能力。结果表明,无论基体相对于夹杂是软质的还是硬质的,采用割线模量方法均能很好地评估复合材料整体的力学响应。而纯弹性方法仅在基体为硬相时,其评估结果才与割线模量方法一致。当基体为软相时,后者对整体力学响应的评估过于刚硬,显著高于实验值。考虑到模型的可扩展性,本工作选用割线模量法处理基体的弹塑性行为。

基于割线模量法,在单轴拉伸状态下,经过割线处理后,材料的割线Young's模量E0s、割线Poisson比v0s与基体的对应弹性参数、流变应力和等效塑性应变之间的关系为[43]:

E0s=11E0+ε0pσf,0
v0s=12-12-v0E0sE0

在弹性状态下,E0s=E0,v0s=v0。基体的割线剪切模量则表示为μ0s=E0s21+v0s,L0,ijkls=2μ0sIijkld+3κ0Iijklh。

1.4 基于位错理论的双峰结构异构基元的受力分析及本构方程

如图2a所示,在异质结构铜的典型结构中,软/硬域界面两侧的晶粒尺寸差异显著,导致了两域强韧性的差异[24]。将两种不同尺度的晶粒直接混合,由于力学性质差异,变形过程中界面处产生变形不相容性[26,55]。由 式(17)和(18)可知,为保持域间的协同变形,两域间存在扰动应变(或称应变配分)。这种动态协调过程,不仅包含位错的随机产生、存储与湮灭,还包括其他协调变形的机制。这些机制带来了HDI强化和应变硬化等效应,进而影响异构材料整体的强韧性[2,26,53,56~60]。

图2

图2   软域硬化示意图

Fig.2   Schematics of soft zone hardening (σ—stress; ρ—density; ρ1G—GND density within soft zone; σ1G—isotropic hardening caused by GNDs within soft zone; σ1B—back stress caused by GNDs within soft zone; σ1M—incremental stress within soft zone; ρ0S, ρ1S—statistically stored dislocation density within hard zone and soft zone, respectively; σ0S, σ1S—isotropic hardening caused by statistically stored dislocations within hard zone and soft zone, respectively)

(a) schematic of the microstructure near the hetero-zone boundary

(b1, b2) TEM image of dislocation pile-ups within the soft zone (b1)[22] and schematic of GND distribution (b2) (The yellow lines are pile-ups of GNDs in a recrystallized grain after tensile deformation for a strain of 5%)

(c, d) dislocation density variation (c) and stress variation (d) near the black horizontal line at the hetero-zone boundaries in Fig.2a due to mismatch strengthening


由于 式(7)的本构关系中仅考虑了均质材料中统计存储位错带来的各向同性硬化,无法计算针对异构材料的式(12)~(15)中两域的应力状态。因此,需要依据实验结果,将变形机制引入到本构关系中,从而计算出各域的流变应力,最后求解出异构基元内部的应力/应变。需要指出的是,在Mori-Tanaka平均场模型中,由于扰动应变的存在,对应界面处两侧的应力并不连续[57]。

基于实验结果,本工作通过三个步骤将两域间协调变形机制引入平均场模型,建立了异构基元的本构关系,具体分析如下。

(1) 软域硬化。在变形初始阶段,由于异构界面两侧晶粒塑性变形不兼容并在三维空间相互约束,在界面附近会产生应变梯度[1,2],并形成了协调应变梯度的GNDs,如图2b1和b2[22]所示。这些GNDs对应变硬化有两方面贡献[28,30]:① 与SSDs (式(7))类似,可产生各向同性硬化,此时应力增量σ1G=Mαμbρ1G [27,28,45,61] (上标“G”表示GND);② GNDs在界面处分布,形成了长程背应力场,产生晶间背应力强化,从而产生背应力硬化,此时应力增量为σ1B[28,30,62,63]。由软域应变梯度引起的ρ1G和总应力增量(σ1M=σ1G+σ1B)分布分别如图2c和d所示。

随着软域塑性变形的进行,其内GNDs的增殖与湮灭逐渐趋于平衡[64]。软域中GNDs由域间塑性剪切应变差Δγ1=3ε1p-ε0p产生,ρ1G的计算公式见 式(23)和(24),具体的推导过程见补充材料附录1。

dρ1GdΔγ1=1d1b-k3ρ1G
ρ1G=1k3d1b1-exp(-k3Δγ1)

式中,k3为异构界面处的位错动态恢复速率因子。

σ1B可表示为:

σ1B=3Ah1ρ1G

式中,A=μb / [π1-v],h1为软域位错塞积列的间距。

(2) 硬域软化。位错塞积不仅在软域内产生了背应力,而且在硬域侧产生一定的应力场,即前应力σ0F[1],这种力可促使域界面处的晶界向硬域内发射位错,并促使硬域内部已缠结位错发生反向滑移或交互滑移,使位错胞解缠、位错偶对消[2,65~69],进而减少位错密度。基于上述实验结果[69](参见文献[69]),硬/软区位错演化示意图如图3a所示,硬域内位错密度减量(ρ(0)I)和硬区软化量(σ(0)I)的分布示意图分别如图3b和c所示。

图3

图3   硬域软化示意图

Fig.3   Schematics of hard zone softening (ρ0I—the change of dislocation density (reduction), σ0I—the change of hard-zone stress (softening), σ0F—forward stress)

(a) dislocation evolution near hard/soft regions during plastic deformation (SSD—statistically stored dislocation)

(b, c) dislocation density variation (b) and stress variation (c) near the hetero-zone boundaries due to strain path change


塞积位错前端作用于硬域的应力构成了一部分前应力,由该应力(τ(0)F)引发的GND变化量ρ(0)I可近似表达为:

ρ0I=-kIρ1G2

式中,kI=λd1h12d0为材料几何参数,λ为应力场衰减因子。具体的推导过程见补充材料附录2。

(3) 硬/软域应力再协调。随着塑性变形的进一步发生,软域硬化和硬域软化并不足以持续协调硬域内的局部应力集中状态。软/硬域应当还存在由上述两种机制的引入而引发的再协调机制,从而保证协同变形的持续进行,而本工作依靠变形带的演变实现这一过程。

基于实验发现,双峰结构铜界面附近的硬域内会形成非等轴状的位错胞(微变形带),这些变形软带以叠加排列的形式扩展时会形成一种更宽的条带状变形区,即剪切带[19,70];而软域的存在可稳定这些本应失稳而快速扩展的剪切带,促进了大量且分散的剪切带在硬域中形成[71~73],如图4a[19]所示。这些剪切带内复杂的应力状态可激活在均质结构中难启动的变形机制,实现了去应变局域化;其在容纳更多应变的同时也为硬域带来了额外的应变硬化。剪切带内部位错由SSD和GND构成,在实验中观测到的高应变区多数由GND提供[74],其密度记为ρ0G,即剪切带内GND密度;类似于软域中的GND强化,ρ0G可产生各向同性硬化(σ0G)和背应力硬化(σ0B)。

图4

图4   应力再协调示意图

Fig.4   Schematics of stress re-partitioning (ρ0G—GND density within shear band, ρ1GM—geo-mismatch dislocation density, σ0SB—shear band hardening, σ1GM—geo-mismatch dislocation hardening)

(a) EBSD image of bimodal structure Cu and its strain maps with 13.54% strain (The solid lines outline the boundaries of soft zones)[19]

(b, c) dislocation density variation (b) and stress variation (c) near the hetero-zone boundaries after inter-zone stress re-partitioning


此外,软域内ρ1G表征了局部晶格失配程度。随着塑性变形的进行,局部晶格失配同样阻碍了晶内位错的滑移,促进了晶内SSDs的存储[30,75],其位错密度记为ρ1GM。硬域和软域内相关位错密度和应力的分布示意图分别见图4b和c。其中,剪切带带来的强化效果记为σ0SB=σ0G+σ0B。

(1) 基于剪切带强化的硬域本构。ρ0G演化可表示为[28]:

ρ0G=f0SBη0SBb=1-exp(-β0SBε0p)γ0SBbd0

式中,上标“SB”表示剪切带;f0SB=1-exp (-β0SBε0p)为剪切带占硬域比例,β0SB=min f1 / f1sat, 1为应变无关常数,表示低应变下剪切带扩展速率,其受层错能、应变速率、软域含量等因素的影响,f1sat为剪切带稳态扩展时对应的软域饱和含量;η0SB为剪切带局部塑性应变梯度;γ0SB为剪切带内晶粒饱和累积剪切应变。与 式(25)相同,由ρ0G引起的背应力硬化σ0B可表示为:

σ0B=3Ah0ρ0G=3Ah0γ0SB1-exp (-β0SBε0p)bd0

式中,h0为硬域内GND塞积列的间距。具体的推导过程见补充材料附录3。

(2) 失配强化的软域本构。随着塑性应变的进行,软域内的GNDs密度逐渐上升,这些位错所描述的局部晶格失配同样阻碍了内部SSDs的滑移[30],因而 式(8)可修正为:

d ρ1SRd ε1p=Mk0bd+k1bρ1SR+ϱ1G-k2ρ1SR

式中,ρ1SR为修正后的软域SSDs密度,ϱ1G为软域内累积GNDs密度。

综上所述,基于 式(7),在忽略了较小的σ0后,双峰结构铜基元内引入了前应力效应(对应的应力为σ0FSE)的硬域和背应力效应(对应的应力为σ1BSE)的软域的流变应力(σf,0和σf,1)可表示为:

σf,0=σ0S+σ0FSE=Mαμbρ0S+ρ0I+ρ0G+σ0B
σf,1=σ1S+σ1BSE=Mαμbρ1SR+ρ1G+σ1B

因而,在单轴拉伸过程中,均匀牵引力边界条件下,拉伸方向的应力σA,11已知,σA,kk=σA,11,σA,ij'=2σA,11 / 3。通过联立式(5)、(6)、(14)、(15)、(30)和(31),可求解得到当前应力状态下的εijH、ε1,ijp和ε0,ijp,进而求得异构基元及各域的应力/应变。

1.5 异质变形诱导强化与应变硬化效应

σ1BSE定义为相同外应变下软域的强度与软域本征应变硬化强度的差值,σ0FSE定义为硬域的强度与硬域本征应变硬化强度的差值,HDI效应带来的强度变化(σHHDI)定义为背应力效应与前应力效应所带来的强度变化的加权求和,三者的计算公式为:

σ1BSE=σf,1-Mαμbρ1S
σ0FSE=σf,0-Mαμbρ0S
σHHDI=f0σ0FSE+f1σ1BSE

此外,在本工作的断裂判据中,基元颈缩点对应的抗拉强度与均匀延伸率采用如下的Considère准则[76]进行计算:

θH / σH,eq=∂σH,eq∂εH,eq/ σH,eq≤1

式中,θH为应变硬化率,σH,eq为异构基元等效应力,εH,eq为异构基元等效应变。

综上,本工作基于Mori-Tanaka平均场方法,结合塑性应变梯度与位错理论,将塑性变形过程中产生的HDI效应以软域硬化、硬域软化和应力再协调三个阶段引入各相的本构关系中,最终构建出双峰结构细观力学模型的框架,如图5所示。

图5

图5   双峰结构细观力学模型的框架

Fig.5   The framework of the micromechanics model for the bimodal structure (σ0 and σ1—average stresses within hard zone and soft zone, respectively;σA—applied stress; ε0 and ε1—average strains within hard zone and soft zone, respectively; εD—disturbance strain; εp1—accumulated plastic strain within soft zone; σf,0 and σf,1—flow stresses of hard zone and soft zone, respectively; M, α, μ, and b—Taylor factor, Taylor constant, shear modulus, and Burgers vector magnitude, respectively; σ0B—back stress hardening of shear band; ρ1SR—revised statistically stored dislocation density; σ1BSE, σ0FSE, and σHHDI—stresses caused by back stress effect, forward stress effect, and HDI effect, respectively; εij, εije, and εijp—total strain, elastic strain, and plastic strain, respectively; εp—equivalent plastic strain; σeq—equivalent stress;σij and σij'—stress and deviatoric stress, respectively; Mijkl—compliance tensor; B0, B1, C0, and C1—Mori-Tanaka mean-field scheme related tensors; f(0), f(1)—volume fractions of hard zone and soft zone, respectively)


2 模拟结果与讨论

2.1 双峰结构铜中异构基元的力学分析

本工作选取的双峰结构铜的实验数据来自文献[4],其制备过程如下:纯Cu (99.99%)棒材首先在液氮温度下进行变形量为93%的冷轧处理,而后在200 ℃下退火3 min。制备得到的双峰结构铜的几何参数为:f1 = 25%,d1 = 3 μm,Γ1 = 6 μm,d0 = 230 nm。本模型材料参数源自实验[4]及模拟[28]结果,部分参数依据文献[24]的方法进行评估,数值汇总于表1。

表1   双峰结构铜的材料和模拟参数

Table 1  Material parameters for bimodal structure Cu

Parameter typeSymbolUnitParameter valueNote
Hard zoneSoft zone
Elastic modulusEGPa121.1121.11*
Shear modulusμGPa45.245.2
Poisson's ratiov-0.340.34
Burgers vector magnitudebnm0.2560.256
Taylor factorM-3.063.06
Taylor constantα-0.330.33
Rate sensitivity exponentm-2020
Initial dislocation densityρ0m-26.7 × 10141.89 × 10132*
Geometric factork0-2.200.08
Proportionality factork1-0.1500.013
Dynamic recovery factork2-39.81.31
Size of zoneΓμm-6
Dislocation pileup spacinghnm15423*
Dynamic recovery factor of GNDsk3-7
Stress attenuation factorλ-0.1
Saturation accumulated shear strainγ0SB-0.20-

Note: 1*: elastic constants and Taylor-related parameters from ref.[28], 2*: correlation coefficients for the Kocks-Mecking-Estrin (KME) model by fitting the experimental data of homogeneous Cu from ref.[4], 3*: h1 from ref.[28]. The remaining parameters (h0, k3,and γ0SB) for the constitutive model of bimodal Cu by fitting the experimental data of bimodal Cu from ref.[4]

新窗口打开| 下载CSV


图6为双峰结构铜的整体和各域的拉伸应力-应变曲线模拟结果,并与实验值[4]进行比较。图6a中,预测的屈服强度、抗拉强度、均匀延伸率分别为328 MPa、540 MPa、25.0%,对应的实验值[4]为328 MPa、539 MPa、25.5%,整体误差均小于10%,证明了本模型的可靠性。图6b展示了在加载过程中GND密度演变,其计算结果与实验[74]中双峰结构铜GND密度量级相近,证明了模型的有效性。

图6

图6   双峰结构铜平均场模型的模拟结果及与实验值[4,74]的比较

Fig.6   Predicted results from the mean-field model for bimodal structure Cu during tensile loading (ε(0) and ε(1)—strains in hard zone and soft zone, respectively) and comparision with experiment results[4,74]

(a, b) comparison of the stress-strain relationship (a) and the GND density evolution (b) between the experiments[4,74] and theoretical results for bimodal structure Cu

(c) stress-strain curves and strain partitioning of each zone (inset) in bimodal structure Cu

(d) evaluation of hardening caused by HDI effect


图6c为拉伸过程中双峰结构铜内各域的应力-应变响应,虚线表示当外加应变为10%时,各域的应变分配状态。从软/硬域的应变比ε1 / ε0的变化可知,软域承担着更多的应变;ε1 / ε0随外应变增加逐渐增加达到最高值5.0,而后逐渐降低为颈缩时的3.5。

对比图6a与c可知,相较于均质细晶相(抗拉强度450 MPa、均匀延伸率2.7%),双峰结构铜中的硬域可持续地应变硬化,这可能源于内部剪切带的稳定扩展。一般认为,剪切带起源于局域软化[77~79],且变形速率越低,剪切带越容易形成[80],剪切带或裂纹扩展是均质材料失稳的根源。而在双峰结构铜中,剪切带或裂纹前端的应力集中可被软域有效释放,使变形更均匀[31],提高了整体稳定性;软域通过承担更多的应变来降低相邻硬域的应变速率,促进异质界面附近硬域剪切带的形核,提高剪切带分布的均匀性。

图6d为HDI效应对双峰结构铜强度的影响。根据式(32)~(34)计算得到的背应力、前应力、HDI效应分别为软域、硬域、整体贡献了169、119和131 MPa的强化值,并与实验测得梯度结构铜的HDI效果(140 MPa[81]和114 MPa[82])相近。

2.2 HDI效应对双峰结构铜力学行为的影响

将双峰结构铜中HDI效应的各类强化、软化作用分成T1~T6项,研究各项对力学性能的贡献,基于 式(30)和(31),这些模型所采用的本构关系参见表2。

表2   考虑不同影响因素的本构方程

Table 2  Constitutive equations considering different influencing factors

No.Stress componentConstitutive equation
T1With HDI effectσf,0=Mαμbρ0S+ρ0I+ρ0G+σ1Bσf,1=Mαμbρ1SR+ρ1G+σ1B
T2Without HDI effectσf,0=Mαμbρ0Sσf,1=Mαμbρ1S
T3Without forward stress (FS) effectσf,0=Mαμbρ0Sσf,1=Mαμbρ1SR+ρ1G+σ1B
T4Without hard zone softeningσf,0=Mαμbρ0S+ρ0G+σ0Bσf,1=Mαμbρ1SR+ρ1G+σ1B
T5Without shear band hardeningσf,0=Mαμbρ0S+ρ0Iσf,1=Mαμbρ1SR+ρ1G+σ1B
T6Without compensating dislocation effectσf,0=Mαμbρ0S+ρ0I+ρ0G+σ1Bσf,1=Mαμbρ1S+ρ1G+σ1B

新窗口打开| 下载CSV


图7对比了不同HDI效应项的计算结果。当忽略HDI效应后(T2),延伸率降低了16.5%,表明HDI效应有效提升了双峰结构铜的应变硬化能力。当忽略前应力效应后(T3),延伸率下降了17.5%;由此可见,前应力效应是提升延伸率的主要因素,占据了整体延伸率的70.0%。在依次剔除硬域软化、剪切带强化、失配强化等作用后(T4~T6),延伸率分别下降了1.2%、18.0%、1.0%,说明硬域内的剪切带强化是HDI效应中提升延伸率的主要因素。

图7

图7   双峰结构铜中各类强化/软化单一因素对力学性能的影响

Fig.7   Influences of strengthening/softening effects on the mechanical properties in bimodal structure Cu

(a, b) theoretical results of stress-strain curves for T1-T3 (a) and T4-T6 (b) considering various hardening and softening factors (HZ—hard zone, SB—shear band, GM—geo-mismatch)

(c) effect of different factors on ultimate tensile strength and uniform elongation


通过上述定量计算可以看到,这与软域负责提升拉伸塑性的传统观点有较大偏差[27]。Bach等[6]指出,双峰结构中硬域的位错演化仍受到晶界处位错的热激活湮灭主导。高体积分数的纳米晶中位错密度在塑性变形初期便达到了饱和,导致过低的本征应变硬化能力。对于拉伸塑性优异的双峰结构材料,剪切带的去局域应变协调机制是必然发生的,剪切带能否稳定扩展成为双峰结构能否稳定应变硬化的主要因素。而软域主要起协调硬域变形的作用,当软域无法抑制硬域中剪切带的失稳扩展时,双峰结构的拉伸塑性不会得到显著的提升[40]。

当忽略硬域软化后,延伸率降低1.2%,类似趋势在离散位错动力学模拟中也有观察到[83]。由于软域自身的硬化能力有上限,过硬的硬域会导致变形过程中更多的应变分配到软域,使得软域中应变硬化能力更早饱和,从而降低了双峰结构铜的拉伸塑性。同时,硬域软化在变形初期可有效消除硬域内的应力集中,当硬域软化足够强时,在变形前期可能会导致异质结构发生非连续屈服现象[63]。

以上结果表明,在设计双峰结构时,软域作为夹杂相,主要作用是协调变形;硬域作为基体,其应变硬化行为显著影响整体的力学性能。硬域与软域的相对强度差异越大,软域承担的应变越多,则可以更好地保护硬域。此外,更软的软域具有更低的裂纹驱动力和更高的裂纹抵抗力,对裂纹扩展的抑制效果越好[84],进而促进硬域内剪切带的稳定扩展。

2.3 软域的体积含量对双峰结构铜力学性能的影响

为了进一步定量评估软域体积分数对双峰结构铜力学性能的影响,通过改变软域的体积分数(5%~65%),计算了不同软域体积分数下双峰结构铜的屈服强度和均匀延伸率。为了便于与实验值比较,将计算结果转换为工程应力/应变,计算结果如图8所示。

图8

图8   当软域体积分数为5%~65%时,双峰结构铜的屈服强度、抗拉强度、均匀延伸率的变化趋势

Fig.8   Variations of yield strength, ultimate tensile strength, and uniform elongation of bimodal structure Cu when the volume fraction of the soft zone is 5%~65%


研究[24]发现,当软域含量较少时,变形过程中大量的应变被分配到硬域,受晶界处的位错热激活湮灭的影响,拉伸塑性较差。当软域的体积分数为25%~30%时,存在强塑匹配最佳的峰值,这与双峰结构铜的一些实验趋势[4,6,19,74]相吻合,计算出的屈服强度为303~320 MPa、抗拉强度为417~420 MPa、均匀延伸率为28.2%~29.8%,此时,延伸率出现了一个平台区,而屈服/抗拉强度的变化幅度较低,这为通过双峰结构设计优化对应的制备工艺的参数提供了理论指导。进一步提升软域的含量,整体的强度快速降低。

需要指出的是,本工作模型均建立在“软域在硬域中均匀分布”假设,根据 式(1),软域均匀分布在硬域内的临界体积分数是66.2%,当超过该含量后,软域会包围硬域,需要重新建模。

图9为不同软域体积分数下,双峰结构铜的强度与延伸率的关系,并与均质结构铜的实验力学性能[85]进行对比。结果显示,具有强度与拉伸塑性协同效应的双峰结构铜的抗拉强度(417~420 MPa)和均匀延伸率(28.2%~29.8%),较均质细晶铜的强度降低约7%,但塑性提升近10倍,而较均质粗晶铜的强度提高了约100%,塑性降低约50%。同时,不含HDI双峰结构铜的力学性能与均质铜相近,显著低于双峰结构铜。这为开发具有高强度-拉伸塑性协同效应的双峰结构铜合金提供了理论指导和精准设计策略。

图9

图9   双峰结构铜的强度-拉伸塑性关系图

Fig.9   Predicted strength-ductility map for Cu (BS—bimodal structure, US—uniform structure)


3 结论

(1) 基于Mori-Tanaka平均场方案结合位错理论,建立了双峰结构金属铜异构基元的细观力学模型,其中大尺寸微米级晶粒(3 μm)作为软域,小尺寸纳米级晶粒(230 nm)作为硬域。与拉伸实验数据相比,其整体应力误差小于5%,验证了模型的有效性。

(2) 提出了将塑性变形过程中产生的HDI效应以软域硬化、硬域软化和应力再协调三个阶段引入各相的本构关系中,可定量地评估HDI效应对双峰结构材料整体力学行为的影响。

(3) 模拟结果表明,当硬域完全包裹软域时,计算出的硬域软化与强化对协调异构组织变形的作用约占70.0%,因此HDI效应主要取决于前应力效应,硬域内的剪切带强化是HDI效应中提升延伸率的主要因素。

(4) 随着硬域体积分数的增加,前应力的作用减弱,整体强度增加而拉伸塑性下降;在软域体积分数为25%~30%时,存在强塑匹配最佳的峰值,双峰结构铜的抗拉强度为417~420 MPa、延伸率为28.2%~29.8%,相较于均质细晶,强度降低约7%、拉伸塑性提高约10倍,相较均质粗晶,强度提高了约100%,拉伸塑性降低约50%。

参考文献

Zhu Y T, Wu X L.

Heterostructured materials

[J]. Prog. Mater. Sci., 2023, 131: 101019

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 3]

Wu X L, Zhu Y T.

Heterostructured metallic materials: Plastic deformation and strain hardening

[J]. Acta Metall. Sin., 2022, 58: 1349

DOI      [本文引用: 5]

Strong and tough metallic materials are desired for light-weight structural applications in transportation and aerospace industries. Recently, heterostructures have been found to possess unprecedented strength-and-ductility synergy, which is until now considered impossible to achieve. Heterostructured metallic materials comprise heterogeneous zones with dramatic variations (> 100%) particularly in mechanical properties. The interaction in these hetero-zones produces a synergistic effect wherein the integrated property exceeds the prediction by the rule-of-mixtures. More importantly, the heterostructured materials can be produced by current industrial facilities at large scale and low cost. The superior properties of heterostructured materials are attributed to the heterodeformation induced (HDI) strengthening and strain hardening, which is produced by the piling-up of geometrically necessary dislocations (GNDs). These GNDs are needed to accommodate the strain gradient near hetero-zone boundaries, across which there is high mechanical incompatibility and strain partitioning. This paper classifies the types of heterostructures and delineates the deformation behavior and mechanisms of heterostructured materials.

武晓雷, 朱运田.

异构金属材料及其塑性变形与应变硬化

[J]. 金属学报, 2022, 58: 1349

DOI      [本文引用: 5]

金属材料异构(heterostructure)是将具有显著流变应力差异的软硬相间区域作为基元进行有序构筑而成的微观组织,是旨在提高应变硬化能力和拉伸塑性的微结构设计策略,迄今应用于各种金属结构材料并获得了强度与塑性/韧性等力学性能的优异匹配。异构策略的出发点是其特征的力学响应,即塑性变形时在异构基元界面形成的应变梯度,异构的特征应力应变响应是力学迟滞环。相比均质结构中主导的林位错塑性和林硬化,异构为了协调界面应变梯度而产生几何必需位错,新增了基于几何必需位错的异质塑性变形并引起额外的应变硬化与额外的强化。本文综述了近期异构金属材料的研究进展,首先定义了异构中基元并据此把异构分类为基元异构、亚基元异构以及复合异构,随后分析并讨论了异构塑性变形时界面和位错等微结构演化,以及异质塑性变形、应变硬化和强化行为,最后展望了异构提升宏观力学性能匹配的潜力。

Tellkamp V L, Lavernia E J, Melmed A.

Mechanical behavior and microstructure of a thermally stable bulk nanostructured Al alloy

[J]. Metall. Mater. Trans., 2001, 32A: 2335

[本文引用: 1]

Wang Y M, Chen M W, Zhou F H, et al.

High tensile ductility in a nanostructured metal

[J]. Nature, 2002, 419: 912

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 12]

Li Y S, Zhang Y, Tao N R, et al.

Effect of thermal annealing on mechanical properties of a nanostructured copper prepared by means of dynamic plastic deformation

[J]. Scr. Mater., 2008, 59: 475

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Bach J, Stoiber M, Schindler L, et al.

Deformation mechanisms and strain rate sensitivity of bimodal and ultrafine-grained copper

[J]. Acta Mater., 2020, 186: 363

DOI      [本文引用: 4]

Materials with ultrafine grain size in the range from 100 nm to 1 mu m exhibit very high strength paired with a satisfactory ductility when compared to their coarse grained (CG) counterparts. Although this typical behavior is already well known, the dominating deformation mechanisms are still controversially discussed in literature. One idea to explain the deformation behavior of ultrafine-grained metals is that deformation is mainly triggered by grain boundary sliding. Another explanation is that deformation in ultrafine-grained materials is controlled by the thermally activated dislocation annihilation of dislocations at grain boundaries. To gain deeper insights to the relevant deformation mechanisms in UFG metals a systematic study was conducted where the deformation behavior of UFG and bimodal copper (consisting of UFG and CG grains) is compared to the behavior of their CG counterparts. The UFG microstructure was obtained by equal channel angular pressing (ECAP). To achieve a bimodal or coarsened microstructure, specimens were annealed at 125 degrees C or, respectively, at 140 degrees C subsequent to the ECAP-process. Mechanical characterization and investigation on the strain-rate sensitivity were done by compression strain-rate jump tests at room-temperatures and elevated temperatures. It turned out clearly that the degree of bimodality determines the dominant deformation mechanism and the strain-rate sensitivity. In the UFG-state thermally activated annihilation of dislocations at the grain boundaries govern the mechanical behavior. For the bimodal microstructure the annihilation of dislocation at the interface of coarsened grains to the surrounding ultrafine-grained matrix dominate the mechanical behavior. For the fully coarsened state plastic deformation is mainly governed by dislocation interaction in the grain interior. In this regime, annihilation at grain boundaries plays only a minor role. (C) 2020 Acta Materialia Inc. Published by Elsevier Ltd.

Qian T, Karaman I, Marx M.

Mechanical properties of nanocrystalline and ultrafine-grained nickel with bimodal microstructure

[J]. Adv. Eng. Mater., 2014, 16: 1323

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Prasad M J N V, Suwas S, Chokshi A H.

Microstructural evolution and mechanical characteristics in nanocrystalline nickel with a bimodal grain-size distribution

[J]. Mater. Sci. Eng., 2009, A503: 86

[本文引用: 1]

Tejedor R, Rodríguez-Baracaldo R, Benito J A, et al.

Plastic deformation of a nanostructured and ultra-fine grained Fe-1%Cr with a bimodal grain size distribution

[J]. Int. J. Mater. Form., 2008, 1: 487

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Fan G J, Choo H, Liaw P K, et al.

Plastic deformation and fracture of ultrafine-grained Al-Mg alloys with a bimodal grain size distribution

[J]. Acta Mater., 2006, 54: 1759

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Lee Z, Radmilovic V, Ahn B, et al.

Tensile deformation and fracture mechanism of bulk bimodal ultrafine-grained Al-Mg alloy

[J]. Metall. Mater. Trans., 2010, 41A: 795

Shakoori Oskooie M, Asgharzadeh H, Kim H S.

Microstructure, plastic deformation and strengthening mechanisms of an Al-Mg-Si alloy with a bimodal grain structure

[J]. J. Alloys Compd., 2015, 632: 540

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

He J H, Jin L, Wang F H, et al.

Mechanical properties of Mg-8Gd-3Y-0.5Zr alloy with bimodal grain size distributions

[J]. J. Magnes. Alloy., 2017, 5: 423

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 2]

Xu C, Fan G H, Nakata T, et al.

Deformation behavior of ultra-strong and ductile Mg-Gd-Y-Zn-Zr alloy with bimodal microstructure

[J]. Metall. Mater. Trans., 2018, 49A: 1931

Zhang H, Wang H Y, Wang J G, et al.

The synergy effect of fine and coarse grains on enhanced ductility of bimodal-structured Mg alloys

[J]. J. Alloys Compd., 2019, 780: 312

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Jin Z Z, Zha M, Yu Z Y, et al.

Exploring the Hall-Petch relation and strengthening mechanism of bimodal-grained Mg-Al-Zn alloys

[J]. J. Alloys Compd., 2020, 833: 155004

DOI      URL    

Wei X X, Jin L, Wang F H, et al.

High strength and ductility Mg-8Gd-3Y-0.5Zr alloy with bimodal structure and nano-precipitates

[J]. J. Mater. Sci. Technol., 2020, 44: 19

DOI     

To resolve the strength-ductility trade-off problem for high-strength Mg alloys, we prepared a high performance Mg-8Gd-3Y-0.5 Zr (wt%) alloy with yield strength of 371 MPa, ultimate tensile strength of 419 MPa and elongation of 15.8%. The processing route involves extrusion, pre-deformation and aging, which leads to a bimodal structure and nano-precipitates. Back-stress originated from the deformation-incompatibility in the bimodal-structure alloy can improve ductility. In addition, dislocation density in coarse grains increased during the pre-deformation strain of 2%, and the dislocations in coarse grains can promote the formation of chain-like nano-precipitates during aging treatment. The chain-like nano-precipitates can act as barriers for dislocations slip and the existing mobile dislocations enable good ductility.

Liu S S, Zhang J L, Chen X, et al.

Improving mechanical properties of heterogeneous Mg-Gd alloy laminate via accumulated extrusion bonding

[J]. Mater. Sci. Eng., 2020, A785: 139324

[本文引用: 1]

Wang Y F, Huang C X, He Q, et al.

Heterostructure induced dispersive shear bands in heterostructured Cu

[J]. Scr. Mater., 2019, 170: 76

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 5]

Li G D, Morinaka S, Kawabata M, et al.

Improvement of strength with maintaining ductility of harmonic structure pure copper by cold rolling and annealing process

[J]. Procedia Manuf., 2018, 15: 1641

[本文引用: 1]

Park H K, Ameyama K, Yoo J, et al.

Additional hardening in harmonic structured materials by strain partitioning and back stress

[J]. Mater. Res. Lett., 2018, 6: 261

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Wu X L, Yang M X, Yuan F P, et al.

Heterogeneous lamella structure unites ultrafine-grain strength with coarse-grain ductility

[J]. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 2015, 112: 14501

DOI      PMID      [本文引用: 3]

Grain refinement can make conventional metals several times stronger, but this comes at dramatic loss of ductility. Here we report a heterogeneous lamella structure in Ti produced by asymmetric rolling and partial recrystallization that can produce an unprecedented property combination: as strong as ultrafine-grained metal and at the same time as ductile as conventional coarse-grained metal. It also has higher strain hardening than coarse-grained Ti, which was hitherto believed impossible. The heterogeneous lamella structure is characterized with soft micrograined lamellae embedded in hard ultrafine-grained lamella matrix. The unusual high strength is obtained with the assistance of high back stress developed from heterogeneous yielding, whereas the high ductility is attributed to back-stress hardening and dislocation hardening. The process discovered here is amenable to large-scale industrial production at low cost, and might be applicable to other metal systems.

Zhou X, Li X Y, Lu K.

Stabilizing nanograins in metals with grain boundary relaxation

[J]. Scr. Mater., 2020, 187: 345

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Yasnikov I S, Kaneko Y, Uchida M, et al.

The grain size effect on strain hardening and necking instability revisited from the dislocation density evolution approach

[J]. Mater. Sci. Eng., 2022, A831: 142330

[本文引用: 6]

Bouaziz O, Estrin Y, Bréchet Y, et al.

Critical grain size for dislocation storage and consequences for strain hardening of nanocrystalline materials

[J]. Scr. Mater., 2010, 63: 477

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Wu X L, Zhu Y T.

Heterogeneous materials: A new class of materials with unprecedented mechanical properties

[J]. Mater. Res. Lett., 2017, 5: 527

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 3]

Zhu L L, Lu J.

Modelling the plastic deformation of nanostructured metals with bimodal grain size distribution

[J]. Int. J. Plast., 2012, 30-31: 166

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 5]

Li J J, Lu W J, Chen S H, et al.

Revealing extra strengthening and strain hardening in heterogeneous two-phase nanostructures

[J]. Int. J. Plast., 2020, 126: 102626

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 10]

Cheng Z, Bu L F, Zhang Y, et al.

Unraveling the origin of extra strengthening in gradient nanotwinned metals

[J]. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 2022, 119: e2116808119

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Wang Y F, Zhu Y T, Yu Z J, et al.

Hetero-zone boundary affected region: A primary microstructural factor controlling extra work hardening in heterostructure

[J]. Acta Mater., 2022, 241: 118395

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 6]

Wu H, Fan G H.

An overview of tailoring strain delocalization for strength-ductility synergy

[J]. Prog. Mater. Sci., 2020, 113: 100675

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 2]

Li J J, Qin F, Yan D S, et al.

Shear instability in heterogeneous nanolayered Cu/Zr composites

[J]. J. Mater. Sci. Technol., 2022, 105: 81

DOI      URL    

Wu X L, Yang M X, Li R G, et al.

Plastic accommodation during tensile deformation of gradient structure

[J]. Sci. China Mater., 2021, 64: 1534

DOI     

Fan G H, Miao K S, Li D Y, et al.

Unraveling the strength-ductility synergy of heterostructured metallic materials from the perspective of local stress/strain

[J]. Acta Metall. Sin., 2022, 58: 1427

DOI      [本文引用: 1]

The concurrent enhancement of strength and ductility is an unremitting pursuit in metallic material research. Recently, by deliberately controlling the spatial distribution of domains with substantially different mechanical properties, heterostructured architecture has overcome the limitation of strength-ductility synergy in metallic materials. Mainstream theories, such as hetero-deformation-induced hardening, strain partition, premature local necking delay, and interface affected zone, have provided crucial guidance for the designing of preferable heterostructured metallic materials. These theories suggest that the domains of heterostructured metallic materials present unique local stress and strain characteristics upon loading, accompanying deformation and fracture behaviors that deviate from the predictions of classical theories. In this study, the evolutions of local stress and strain during the early deformation, plastic deformation, and fracture stages of heterostructured metallic materials were reviewed. Moreover, interactions between deformation or fracture behaviors and local stress or strain as well as their effects on mechanical properties are summarized, presenting a new perspective for designing and developing high-performance heterostructured metallic materials.

范国华, 缪克松, 李丹阳 等.

从局域应力/应变视角理解异构金属材料的强韧化行为

[J]. 金属学报, 2022, 58: 1427

DOI      [本文引用: 1]

同步提升强度与塑性是金属材料研究的不懈追求之一。近年来,异构设计通过调控力学性质存在显著差异的组元相的空间分布,突破了金属材料强度与塑性难兼得的瓶颈。异构变形诱导强化、应变分配、延迟颈缩、界面影响区等主流理论为异构金属材料设计提供了有力指导,上述理论均指出,在受载过程中,异构金属材料组元相的局域应力与局域应变存在独特特征,并伴随偏离经典理论预测的变形和断裂行为。本文综述了异构金属材料在早期变形阶段、塑性变形阶段和断裂阶段中局域应力和局域应变演化,归纳了异构金属材料中变形行为、断裂行为与局域应力、局域应变的交互关系及对力学性能的影响,为高性能异构金属材料的设计和研发提供新的思路。

Yuan R, Beyerlein I J, Zhou C Z.

Homogenization of plastic deformation in heterogeneous lamella structures

[J]. Mater. Res. Lett., 2017, 5: 251

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Ma H W, Zhao Y C, Lyu Z, et al.

What are the “dispersive shear bands” on the surfaces of layered heterostructured materials?

[J]. J. Mech. Phys. Solids, 2023, 181: 105467

DOI      URL    

Wang Y F, Huang C X, Li Y S, et al.

Dense dispersed shear bands in gradient-structured Ni

[J]. Int. J. Plast., 2020, 124: 186

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Estrin Y, Vinogradov A.

Extreme grain refinement by severe plastic deformation: A wealth of challenging science

[J]. Acta Mater., 2013, 61: 782

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Peng P, Tang A T, She J, et al.

Significant improvement in yield stress of Mg-Gd-Mn alloy by forming bimodal grain structure

[J]. Mater. Sci. Eng., 2021, A803: 140569

Renk O, Hohenwarter A, Pippan R.

Cyclic deformation behavior of a 316L austenitic stainless steel processed by high pressure torsion

[J]. Adv. Eng. Mater., 2012, 14: 948

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 2]

Huang C X, Wang Y F, Ma X L, et al.

Interface affected zone for optimal strength and ductility in heterogeneous laminate

[J]. Mater. Today, 2018, 21: 713

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Zhu L L, Shi S Q, Lu K, et al.

A statistical model for predicting the mechanical properties of nanostructured metals with bimodal grain size distribution

[J]. Acta Mater., 2012, 60: 5762

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Weng G J.

The overall elastoplastic stress-strain relations of dual-phase metals

[J]. J. Mech. Phys. Solids, 1990, 38: 419

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 5]

Delincé M, Bréchet Y, Embury J D, et al.

Structure-property optimization of ultrafine-grained dual-phase steels using a microstructure-based strain hardening model

[J]. Acta Mater., 2007, 55: 2337

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Gao H J, Huang Y G.

Taylor-based nonlocal theory of plasticity

[J]. Int. J. Solids Struct., 2001, 38: 2615

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 2]

Orowan E.

Zur kristallplastizität. III: Über den mechanismus des gleitvorganges

[J]. Z. Phys., 1934, 89: 634

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Taylor G I.

The mechanism of plastic deformation of crystals. Part I.—Theoretical

[J]. Proc. Roy. Soc., 1934, 145A: 362

[本文引用: 2]

Zerilli F J, Armstrong R W.

Dislocation-mechanics-based constitutive relations for material dynamics calculations

[J]. J. Appl. Phys., 1987, 61: 1816

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

An improved description of copper- and iron-cylinder impact (Taylor) test results has been obtained through the use of dislocation-mechanics-based constitutive relations in the Lagrangian material dynamics computer program EPIC-2. The effects of strain hardening, strain-rate hardening, and thermal softening based on thermal activation analysis have been incorporated into a reasonably accurate constitutive relation for copper. The relation has a relatively simple expression and should be applicable to a wide range of fcc materials. The effect of grain size is included. A relation for iron is also presented. It also has a simple expression and is applicable to other bcc materials but is presently incomplete, since the important effect of deformation twinning in bcc materials is not included. A possible method of acounting for twinning is discussed and will be reported on more fully in future work. A main point made here is that each material structure type (fcc, bcc, hcp) will have its own constitutive behavior, dependent on the dislocation characteristics for that particular structure.

Elmasry A, Azoti W, El-Safty S A, et al.

A comparative review of multiscale models for effective properties of nano- and micro-composites

[J]. Prog. Mater. Sci., 2023, 132: 101022

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Mori T, Tanaka K.

Average stress in matrix and average elastic energy of materials with misfitting inclusions

[J]. Acta Metall., 1973, 21: 571

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Benveniste Y.

A new approach to the application of Mori-Tanaka's theory in composite materials

[J]. Mech. Mater., 1987, 6: 147

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Li J J, Chen S H, Weng G J, et al.

A micromechanical model for heterogeneous nanograined metals with shape effect of inclusions and geometrically necessary dislocation pileups at the domain boundary

[J]. Int. J. Plast., 2021, 144: 103024

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Mura T. Micromechanics of Defects in Solids[M]. 2nd Ed., Dordrecht: Springer, 1987: 188

[本文引用: 3]

Bishop J F W, XLVI Hill R..

A theory of the plastic distortion of a polycrystalline aggregate under combined stresses

[J]. London Edinburgh Dublin Philos. Mag. J. Sci., 1951, 42: 414

[本文引用: 1]

Li J J, Lu W J, Gibson J, et al.

Eliminating deformation incompatibility in composites by gradient nanolayer architectures

[J]. Sci. Rep., 2018, 8: 16216

DOI      PMID      [本文引用: 1]

Composite materials usually possess a severe deformation incompatibility between the soft and hard phases. Here, we show how this incompatibility problem is overcome by a novel composite design. A gradient nanolayer-structured Cu-Zr material has been synthesized by magnetron sputtering and tested by micropillar compression. The interface spacing between the alternating Cu and Zr nanolayers increases gradually by one order of magnitude from 10 nm at the surface to 100 nm in the centre. The interface spacing gradient creates a mechanical gradient in the depth direction, which generates a deformation gradient during loading that accumulates a substantial amount of geometrically necessary dislocations. These dislocations render the component layers of originally high mechanical contrast compatible. As a result, we revealed a synergetic mechanical response in the material, which is characterized by fully compatible deformation between the constituent Cu and Zr nanolayers with different thicknesses, resulting in a maximum uniform layer strain of up to 60% in the composite. The deformed pillars have a smooth surface, validating the absence of deformation incompatibility between the layers. The joint deformation response is discussed in terms of a micromechanical finite element simulation.

Крутков Ю А. Тензор Функций Напряжений И Общие Решения В Статике Теории Упругости[M]. Москва: Изд-во АН СССР, 1949: 1

[本文引用: 1]

Qu J M, Cherkaoui M. Fundamentals of Micromechanics of Solids[M]. Hoboken: Wiley, 2006: 73

[本文引用: 1]

Kachanov M, Sevostianov I. Micromechanics of Materials, with Applications[M]. Cham: Springer, 2018: 391

Shen G L, Hu G K. Mechanics of Composite Materials[M]. Beijing: Tsinghua University Press, 2006: 246

沈观林, 胡更开. 复合材料力学[M]. 北京: 清华大学出版社, 2006: 246

Jiang S, Lin Peng R, Zhao X, et al.

Deformation incompatibility enables hetero-deformation induced strengthening in Ti/Nb laminates

[J]. Mater. Res. Lett., 2023, 11: 126

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Nix W D, Gao H J.

Indentation size effects in crystalline materials: A law for strain gradient plasticity

[J]. J. Mech. Phys. Solids, 1998, 46: 411

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Feaugas X.

On the origin of the tensile flow stress in the stainless steel AISI 316L at 300 K: Back stress and effective stress

[J]. Acta Mater., 1999, 47: 3617

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Yang M X, Pan Y, Yuan F P, et al.

Back stress strengthening and strain hardening in gradient structure

[J]. Mater. Res. Lett., 2016, 4: 145

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 2]

Zhou H, Huang C X, Sha X C, et al.

In-situ observation of dislocation dynamics near heterostructured interfaces

[J]. Mater. Res. Lett., 2019, 7: 376

DOI      [本文引用: 1]

There has been a long-standing controversy on how dislocations interact with interfaces. Here we report in-situ observations that in a Cu-brass heterostructured TEM film Frank-Read sources are the primary dislocation sources. They were dynamically formed and deactivated throughout the deformation in grain interior, which has never been reported before. This observation indicates that strain gradient near interfaces cannot be quantitatively related to the density gradient of geometrically necessary dislocations, and it was primarily produced by Frank-Read source gradient instead of dislocation pile-ups. These findings provide new insights on how to design heterostructured interfaces to enhance mechanical properties. [GRAPHICS]

Hasegawa T, Yakou T, Kocks U F.

Forward and reverse rearrangements of dislocations in tangled walls

[J]. Mater. Sci. Eng., 1986, 81: 189

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Zirkle T, Zhu T, McDowell D L.

Micromechanical crystal plasticity back stress evolution within FCC dislocation substructure

[J]. Int. J. Plast., 2021, 146: 103082

DOI      URL    

Marukawa K, Sanpei T.

Stability of the work hardened state against stress reversal in copper single crystals

[J]. Acta Metall., 1971, 19: 1169

DOI      URL    

Rassweiler G M, Grube W L. Internal Stresses and Fatigue in Metals[M]. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 1959: 1

Wu X L, Jiang P, Chen L, et al.

Extraordinary strain hardening by gradient structure

[J]. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 2014, 111: 7197

DOI      PMID      [本文引用: 3]

Gradient structures have evolved over millions of years through natural selection and optimization in many biological systems such as bones and plant stems, where the structures change gradually from the surface to interior. The advantage of gradient structures is their maximization of physical and mechanical performance while minimizing material cost. Here we report that the gradient structure in engineering materials such as metals renders a unique extra strain hardening, which leads to high ductility. The grain-size gradient under uniaxial tension induces a macroscopic strain gradient and converts the applied uniaxial stress to multiaxial stresses due to the evolution of incompatible deformation along the gradient depth. Thereby the accumulation and interaction of dislocations are promoted, resulting in an extra strain hardening and an obvious strain hardening rate up-turn. Such extraordinary strain hardening, which is inherent to gradient structures and does not exist in homogeneous materials, provides a hitherto unknown strategy to develop strong and ductile materials by architecting heterogeneous nanostructures.

Hirsch J, Lücke K, Hatherly M.

Overview No.76: Mechanism of deformation and development of rolling textures in polycrystalline f.c.c. Metals—III. The influence of slip inhomogeneities and twinning

[J]. Acta Metall., 1988, 36: 2905

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Wang Y F, Huang C X, Li Z K, et al.

Shear band stability and uniform elongation of gradient structured material: Role of lateral constraint

[J]. Extreme Mech. Lett., 2020, 37: 100686

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Wang Y F, Wei Y G, Zhao Z F, et al.

Mechanical response of the constrained nanostructured layer in heterogeneous laminate

[J]. Scr. Mater., 2022, 207: 114310

DOI      URL    

Wang Y F, Wei Y G, Zhao Z F, et al.

Activating dispersed strain bands in tensioned nanostructure layer for high ductility: The effects of microstructure inhomogeneity

[J]. Int. J. Plast., 2022, 149: 103159

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Li G D, Jiang J X, Ma H C, et al.

Superior strength-ductility synergy in three-dimensional heterogeneous-nanostructured metals

[J]. Acta Mater., 2023, 256: 119143

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 6]

Gao H J, Huang Y G.

Geometrically necessary dislocation and size-dependent plasticity

[J]. Scr. Mater., 2003, 48: 113

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

von Considére M. Memoire sur L'emploi du fer et de L'acier Dans les Constructions[M]. Paris: Ch. Dunod, 1885: 1

[本文引用: 1]

Recht R F.

Catastrophic thermoplastic shear

[J]. J. Appl. Mech., 1964, 31: 189

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Dynamic plastic behavior of materials is influenced by internally generated temperature gradients. These gradients are a function of thermophysical properties as well as strain rate and shear strength. Criteria are presented for the prediction of catastrophic shear in materials. Catastrophic shear occurs when the local rate of change of temperature has a negative effect on strength which is equal to or greater than the positive effect of strain-hardening. Catastrophic slip is an influential deformation mechanism during high-speed machining and ballistic impact. Structural failure may occur during dynamic loading of components which are designed without regard to the specific sensitivity of certain materials to catastrophic shear.

Meyers M A, Subhash G, Kad B K, et al.

Evolution of microstructure and shear-band formation in α-hcp titanium

[J]. Mech. Mater., 1994, 17: 175

DOI      URL    

Armstrong R W, Zerilli F J.

Dislocation mechanics aspects of plastic instability and shear banding

[J]. Mech. Mater., 1994, 17: 319

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Xu Y B, Zhang J H, Bai Y L, et al.

Shear localization in dynamic deformation: Microstructural evolution

[J]. Metall. Mater. Trans., 2008, 39A: 811

[本文引用: 1]

Liu X L, Yuan F P, Zhu Y T, et al.

Extraordinary Bauschinger effect in gradient structured copper

[J]. Scr. Mater., 2018, 150: 57

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Yang Y, Gong Y L, Li X F, et al.

Effect of bimodal grain size and gradient structure on heterogeneous deformation induced (HDI) stress and mechanical properties of Cu

[J]. Mater. Res. Express, 2022, 9: 035004

[本文引用: 1]

Shimokawa T, Hasegawa T, Kiyota K, et al.

Heterogeneous evolution of lattice defects leading to high strength and high ductility in harmonic structure materials through atomic and dislocation simulations

[J]. Acta Mater., 2022, 226: 117679

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Wu H, Huang M, Li X W, et al.

Temperature-dependent reversed fracture behavior of multilayered TiBw/Ti-Ti(Al) composites

[J]. Int. J. Plast., 2021, 141: 102998

DOI      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Tian Y Z, Ren Y P, Gao S, et al.

Two-stage Hall-Petch relationship in Cu with recrystallized structure

[J]. J. Mater. Sci. Technol., 2020, 48: 31

DOI      [本文引用: 1]

Although Cu was studied extensively, the Hall-Petch relationship was mainly reported in the coarse-grained regime. In this work, fully recrystallized Cu specimens with a wide grain size regime of 0.51-14.93 μm manifest a two-stage Hall-Petch relationship. There is a critical grain size of 3 μm that divides stages I and II where the Hall-Petch slope k value are quite different. The stage II is supposed to be validified down to 100 nm at least by comparing with a Cu-Ag alloy. The critical grain size varies in different materials systems, and the underline mechanisms are discussed based on the dislocation glide modes.

/

〈 〉