三维Ising模型的数学结构与精确解探索*
收稿日期: 2016-07-27
网络出版日期: 2016-09-07
基金资助
* 国家自然科学基金项目51331006和51590883资助
MATHEMATICAL STRUCTURE AND THE CONJECTURED EXACT SOLUTION OF THREEDIMENSIONAL (3D) ISING MODEL
Received date: 2016-07-27
Online published: 2016-09-07
Supported by
Supported by National Natural Science Foundation of China (Nos.51331006 and 51590883)
本文首先回顾Ising模型的研究历史, 包括Ising模型简介、二维和三维Ising模型的研究进展, 特别是二维Ising模型的精确解. 然后介绍作者提出的有关三维Ising模型的2个猜想以及推定的精确解. 从拓扑、代数和几何的角度对三维Ising模型的数学结构进行了评述. 分析三维Ising模型的转移矩阵、拓扑理论中的纽结变换、Yang-Baxter方程和四面体方程之间的关系, 还介绍了三维Ising模型中存在的非局域效应、与量子场论和规范理论的关系、权重因子的物理意义、无限大温度及附近的奇异性和拓扑相变. 指出一些近似计算方法(例如, 低温展开、高温展开、重整化群和Monte Carlo模拟等)在研究三维Ising模型时的局限性.
张志东 . 三维Ising模型的数学结构与精确解探索*[J]. 金属学报, 2016 , 52(10) : 1311 -1325 . DOI: 10.11900/0412.1961.2016.00336
In this article, the history of study on Ising model was first reviewed briefly, including a brief introduction of Ising model, the advances in the study of two-dimensional (2D) and three-dimensional (3D) Ising models, with a special interest in the exact solution of the 2D Ising model. Then two conjectures and putative exact solution of the 3D Ising model were introduced, and the mathematical structure of the 3D Ising model was investigated from the aspects of topology, algebra and geometry. The transfer matrices of the 3D Ising model, the knot theory in the topology, the relations between the Yang-Baxter equations and the tetrahedron equations were analysized. The non-local effect in the 3D Ising model, the relation between quantum field theory and gauge theory, the physical significance of weight factors, the singularity and the topological phase transition at/near infinite temperature in the 3D Ising model were also discussed. Finally, it was pointed out that some approximation techniques (for examples, low-temperature expansions, high-temperature expansions, renormalization group and Monte Carlo simulations) have disadvantages for studying the 3D Ising model.
| [1] | Ising E.Z Phys, 1925; 31: 253 |
| [2] | Huang K.Statistical Mechanics. New York-London: John Wiley and Sons Inc., 1987: 341 |
| [3] | Domb C, Green M S.Phase Transitions and Critical Phenomena. Vol.3, London: Academic Press, 1974: 1 |
| [4] | Ma S K.Modern Theory of Critical Phenomena. Redwood, CA: Addison-Wesley, 1976: 1 |
| [5] | Bragg W L, Williams E J.Proc Roy Soc, 1934; 145A: 699 |
| [6] | Shockley W.J Chem Phys, 1938; 6: 130 |
| [7] | Kramers H A, Wannier G H.Phys Rev, 1941; 60: 252 |
| [8] | Kramers H A, Wannier G H.Phys Rev, 1941; 60: 263 |
| [9] | Montroll E W.J Chem Phys, 1941; 9: 706 |
| [10] | Onsager L.Phys Rev, 1944; 65: 117 |
| [11] | Kaufman B.Phys Rev, 1949; 76: 1232 |
| [12] | Yang C N.Phys Rev, 1952; 85: 808 |
| [13] | Newell G F, Montroll E W.Rev Mod Phys, 1953; 25: 353 |
| [14] | Baxter R J.Exactly Solved Models in Statistical Mechanics. London: Academic Press, 1982: 1 |
| [15] | McCoy B M, Wu T T. The Two-Dimensional Ising Model. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1973: 1 |
| [16] | Yang C N, Lee T D.Phys Rev, 1952; 87: 404 |
| [17] | Lee T D, Yang C N.Phys Rev, 1952; 87: 410 |
| [18] | Domb C.Adv Phys, 1960; 9: 149 |
| [19] | Fisher M E.Rev Mod Phys, 1998; 70: 653 |
| [20] | Rushbrooke G S.J Chem Phys, 1963; 39: 842 |
| [21] | Widom B.J Chem Phys, 1965; 43: 3898 |
| [22] | Kadanoff L P, G?tze W, Hamblen D, Hecht R, Lewis E A S, Palciauskas V V, Rayl M, Swift J, Aspnes D, Kane J.Rev Mod Phys, 1967; 39: 395 |
| [23] | Wilson K G.Phys Rev, 1971; 4B: 3174 |
| [24] | Wilson K G.Phys Rev, 1971; 4B: 3184 |
| [25] | Binder K, Luijten E.Phys Rep, 2001; 344: 179 |
| [26] | Pelissetto A, Vicari E.Phys Rep, 2002; 368: 549 |
| [27] | Zhang Z D.Philos Mag, 2007; 87: 5309 |
| [28] | Zhang Z D.Chin J Nat, 2008; 30: 94 |
| [28] | (张志东. 自然杂志, 2008; 30: 94) |
| [29] | Zhang Z D.Chin Phys, 2013; 22B: 030513 |
| [30] | Lou S L, Wu S H.Chin J Phys, 2000; 38: 841 |
| [31] | Perk J H H.Philos Mag, 2009; 89: 761 |
| [32] | Zhang Z D.Philos Mag, 2009; 89: 765 |
| [33] | Zhang Z D.Philos Mag, 2008; 88: 3097 |
| [34] | ?awrynowicz J, Marchiafava S, Niemczynowicz A.Adv Appl Clifford Alg, 2010; 20: 733 |
| [35] | ?awrynowicz J, Marchiafava S, Nowak-K?pczyk M.In: Sekigawa K, Gerdjikov V S, Dimiev S eds., Trends in Differential Geometry, Complex Analysis and Mathematical Physics, Singapore: World Scientific, 2008: 156 |
| [36] | Lawrynowicz J, Nowak-Kepczyk M, Suzuki O.Int J Bifurcation Chaos, 2012; 22: 1230003 |
| [37] | Lawrynowicz J, Suzuki O, Niemczynowicz A.Adv Appl Clifford Alg, 2012; 22: 757 |
| [38] | Lawrynowicz J, Suzuki O, Niemczynowicz A.Int J Nonlinear Sci Numer Simul, 2013; 14: 211 |
| [39] | Jordan P, von Neumann J, Wigner E.Ann Math, 1934; 35: 29 |
| [40] | de Leo S, Rodrigues Jr W A.Int J Theor Phys, 1997; 36: 2725 |
| [41] | Finkelstein D, Jauch J M, Schiminovich S, Speiser D.J Math Phys, 1962; 3: 207 |
| [42] | de Leo S.J Math Phys, 1996; 37: 2955 |
| [43] | Zhang Z D, March N H.Bull Soc Sci Lett Lód? Sér Rech Déform, 2012; 62: 35 |
| [44] | Kauffman L H.Knots and Physics. 3rd Ed., Singapore: World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd, 2001: 1 |
| [45] | Kauffman L H.Rep Prog Phys, 2005; 68: 2829 |
| [46] | Baxter R J.Ann Phys, 1972; 70: 193 |
| [47] | Perk J H H, Au-Yang H. In: Francoise J P, Naber G L, Tsun T S eds., Yang-Baxter Equations, in the Encyclopedia of Mathematical Physics. Vol.5, Amsterdam: Elsevier Inc., 2007: 465 |
| [48] | Wannier G H.Rev Mod Phys, 1945; 17: 50 |
| [49] | Houtappel R M F.Physica, 1950; 16: 425 |
| [50] | Yang C N, Yang C P.Phys Rev, 1966; 150: 321 |
| [51] | Yang C N.Phys Rev Lett, 1967; 19: 1312 |
| [52] | Shankar R, Witten E.Phys Rev, 1978; 17D: 2134 |
| [53] | Zamolodchikov A B.Sov Phys JETP, 1980; 52: 325 |
| [54] | Zamolodchikov A B.Commun Math Phys, 1981; 79: 489 |
| [55] | Jaekel M T, Maillard J M.J Phys, 1982; 15A: 1309 |
| [56] | Stroganov Y G.Theor Math Phys, 1997; 110: 141 |
| [57] | Witten E.Commun Math Phys, 1988; 118: 411 |
| [58] | Witten E.Nucl Phys, 1989; 322B: 629 |
| [59] | Witten E.Commun Math Phys, 1989; 121: 351 |
| [60] | Atiyah M F.Proc Symp Pure Math, 1988; 48: 285 |
| [61] | Floer A.Bull Am Math Soc, 1987; 16: 279 |
| [62] | Donaldson S.J Differ Geom, 1983; 18: 269 |
| [63] | Donaldson S.J Differ Geom, 1987; 26: 397 |
| [64] | Caselle M, Gliozzi F, Magnea U, Vinti S.Nucl Phys, 1996; 460B: 397 |
| [65] | Caselle M, Fiore R, Gliozzi F, Hasenbusch M, Provero P.Nucl Phys, 1997; 486B: 245 |
| [66] | Witten E.Nucl Phys, 1989; 330B: 285 |
| [67] | Nayak C, Simon S H, Stern A, Freedman M, Sarma S D.Rev Mod Phys, 2008; 80: 1083 |
| [68] | Wu F Y, McCoy B M, Fisher M E, Chayes L.Philos Mag, 2008; 88: 3093 |
| [69] | Wu F Y, McCoy B M, Fisher M E, Chayes L.Philos Mag, 2008; 88: 3103 |
| [70] | Perk J H H.Philos Mag, 2009; 89: 769 |
| [71] | Perk J H H.Chin Phys, 2013; 22B: 080508 |
| [72] | Perk J H H.Bull Soc Sci Lett Lód? Sér Rech Déform, 2012; 62: 45 |
| [73] | Perk J.H. H.Bull Soc Sci Lett Lód? Sér Rech Déform, 2012; 62: 71 |
| [74] | Zhang Z D, March N H.Bull Soc Sci Lett Lód? Sér Rech Déform, 2012; 62: 61 |
| [75] | Sinai Y G.Theory of Phase Transitions: Rigorous Results. Chapter II, Oxford: Pergamon Press, 1982: 29 |
| [76] | Glimm J, Jaffe A.Quantum Physics. 2nd Ed., Chapters 18 and 20, New York: Springer, 1987: 356, 398 |
| [77] | Israel R B.Commun Math Phys, 1976; 50: 245 |
| [78] | Zahradnik M.J Stat Phys, 1987; 47: 725 |
| [79] | Lebowitz J L, Penrose O.Commun Math Phys, 1968; 11: 99 |
| [80] | Griffiths R B.In: Domb C, Green M S eds., Rigorous Results and Theorems, in Phase Transitions and Critical Phenomena. Vol.1, Chapter 2, New York: Academic Press, 1972: 8 |
| [81] | Sachdev S. Quantum Phase Transitions.Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1999: 1 |
| [82] | Gallavotti G, Miracle-Solé S.Commun Math Phys, 1968; 7: 274 |
| [83] | Ruelle D.Statistical Mechanics: Rigorous Results. NY: Benjamin, 1969: 1 |
| [84] | Miracle-Solé S.Lect Notes Phys, 1976; 54: 189 |
| [85] | Gallavotti G, Miracle-Solé S, Robinson D W.Phys Lett, 1967; 25A; 493 |
| [86] | Gallavotti G, Miracle-Solé S.Commun Math Phys, 1967; 5: 317 |
| [87] | Department of Physics of Beijing University. Quantum Statistical Mechanics. Beijing: Beijing University Press, 1987: 90 |
| [87] | (北京大学物理系《量子统计物理学》编写组. 量子统计物理学. 北京: 北京大学出版社, 1987: 90) |
| [88] | Guttmann A J, Enting I G.J Phys, 1993; 26A: 807 |
| [89] | Domb C, Guttmann A J.J Phys, 1970; 3C: 1652 |
| [90] | Bhanot G, Creutz M, Horvath I, Lacki J, Weckel J.Phys Rev, 1994; 49E: 2445 |
| [91] | Fisher M E.Rep Prog Phys, 1967; 30: 615 |
| [92] | Binder K, Luijten E.Phys Rep, 2001; 344: 179 |
| [93] | Pelissetto A, Vicari E.Phys Rep, 2002; 368: 549 |
| [94] | Klein D J, March N H.Phys Lett, 2008; 372A: 5052 |
| [95] | Strecka J, Dely J, Canova L.Physica, 2009; 388: 2394 |
| [96] | March N H, Zhang Z D.Phys Lett, 2009; 373: 2075 |
| [97] | March N H, Zhang Z D.Phys Chem Liquids, 2009; 47: 693 |
| [98] | March N H, Zhang Z D.J Math Chem, 2010; 47: 520 |
| [99] | March N H, Zhang Z D.Phys Chem Liquids, 2010; 48: 279 |
| [100] | Zhang Z D, March N H.Phys Chem Liquids, 2010; 48: 403 |
| [101] | Zhang Z D, March N H.J Math Chem, 2011; 49: 816 |
| [102] | Zhang Z D, March N H.Phys Chem Liquids, 2011; 49: 270 |
| [103] | Zhang Z D, March N H.Phys Chem Liquids, 2011; 49: 684 |
| [104] | Zhang Z D, March N H.J Math Chem, 2011; 49: 1283 |
| [105] | Zhang Z D, March N H.J Math Chem, 2012; 50: 920 |
| [106] | March N H, Zhang Z D.J Math Chem, 2013; 51: 1694 |
| [107] | Zhang Z D, March N H.Phys Chem Liquids, 2013; 51: 261 |
| [108] | Zhang Z D, March N H.Phys Chem Liquids, 2013; 51: 742 |
| [109] | Radzhabova L M, Stepanov G V, Abdulagatov I M.Phys Chem Liquids, 2013; 51: 75 |
| [110] | Kaupu?s J.Can J Phys, 2012; 90: 373 |
| [111] | Kaupuzs J, Melnik R V N, Rimsans J.Commun Computat Phys, 2013; 14: 355 |
| [112] | March N H.Phys Lett, 2014; 378A: 254 |
| [113] | March N H.Phys Chem Liquids, 2014; 52: 697 |
| [114] | March N H.Phys Lett, 2015; 379A: 820 |
| [115] | March N H.Phys Chem Liquids, 2016; 54: 127 |
| [116] | Zeng D F. arXiv:1407.8504 |
/
| 〈 |
|
〉 |
