合金化调控Nb-Si基超高温合金强韧化与抗氧化性能的研究进展
李云龙, 张子润, 于君, 赵占勇, 林鑫, 白培康

Research Progress on Alloying Regulation of Strengthening, Toughening, and Oxidation Resistance in Nb-Si-Based Ultrahigh-Temperature Alloys
LI Yunlong, ZHANG Zirun, YU Jun, ZHAO Zhanyong, LIN Xin, BAI Peikang
表3 Nb-Si基超高温合金中多组元合金化体系的协同效益、风险及应用目标[35,40,61,71~77]
Table 3 Synergistic benefits, risks, and application targets of multicomponent alloying systems in Nb-Si-based ultrahigh-temperature alloys[35,40,61,71-77]

Alloy

combination

Main benefitMain riskBest application target

Zr-Mo[71,75]

Improves phase stability, suppresses Nb3Si, refines microstructure, enhances both toughness and oxidation resistanceNarrow content windows; excess Mo embrittles Nbss and worsens oxidation, excess Zr increases brittle silicideBalanced design for toughness + high- temperature strength + oxidation resistance

Ti-Zr-Hf[40]

Stabilizes favorable silicide constitution, improves phase distribution, retains better strength-toughness balance than single additionsExcess total addition reduces Nbss continuity, raises silicide fraction, increases density/costIntegrated microstructure optimization focusing on phase stability and toughness retention

Cr-Hf[61]

Oxidation-oriented synergy: Cr builds protective external oxides, Hf improves scale adhesion and long-term stabilityStill increases brittle intermetallic fractions; room temperature toughness remains a concern if Cr is too highHigh-temperature oxidation resistance with improved scale stability
Cr-Al[35]Strong oxidation synergy via dense Cr/Al-containing protective scalesweakened Nbss continuity and increased brittle phasesOxidation-prioritized alloy design

Mo-B[73]

Strong high-temperature strengthening synergy via phase regulation + eutectic-path control; overall performance improves with careful B controlB has very narrow safe range; excess B sharply increases brittle silicide, excess Mo narrows toughness marginHigh-temperature strength and microstructure-regulated eutectic design

Zr-Ti[72]

In selected systems, improves room temperature toughness and compressive strength through combined refinement and phase-distribution optimizationBenefits not universal; oxidation benefit is limited and strongly system dependentToughness-oriented or mechanically balanced composition design

Mo-V[74]

May provide selective strengthening in some compositions

Often limited or antagonistic overall benefit; can increase phase complexity and reduce toughness if poorly controlledExploratory strengthening-oriented design, not mainstream balanced route

Ti-Zr-Mo[76]

Combines Ti-assisted phase adjustment, Zr refinement, and Mo-driven Nb3Si suppression; potentially beneficial for overall structural optimizationStrong system dependence; optimum balance shifts with base Si/Ti/Nb ratio and processing routeComprehensive phase-constitution and morphology control

RE-containing multicomponent[77]

Trace RE addition amplifies benefits of other elements via melt purification, interface improvement, oxide-scale stabilization, and microstructural refinementOver-addition introduces oxide inclusions, segregation, or coarse particles, offsetting synergyControlling inclusions, segregation, or coarse particles to preserve synergy