Ti[65] | TiO2-containing composite scale, Ti-rich outer layer; can form denser layer at high temperature | Improves compactness at > 1100 oC | Poor efficacy at lower temperatures; clear temperature window |
Zr[31,58] | ZrO2 particles/regions; improved continuity of inner SiO2 layer | ZrO2 fills defects, reduces porosity, stabilizes protective sublayer | Excess Zr increases brittle silicide fraction and degrades mechanical balance |
Mo[33] | Less porous at suitable content; excessive Mo introduces pores and fast-diffusion paths | Optimizes phase constitution and indirectly retards oxidation at appropriate levels | Narrow beneficial window; overaddition aggravates oxidation via pore formation |
Cr[35,66-68,70] | Forms Cr2O3, CrNbO4, or Cr-enriched outer scale; promotes dense external protective layer | Enhances compactness and slows inward oxygen diffusion | Often sacrifices room temperature toughness |
Al[35,68] | Forms relatively dense Al2O3-containing scale; suppresses loose Nb2O5 growth | Improves scale continuity, compactness, and oxygen-barrier capability | Reduces Nbss continuity and lowers room-temperature toughness |
Ta[39] | Slightly denser scale; in some systems, helps reduce severe scale disruption | Indirectly optimizes phase constitution and oxidation response | Very narrow optimum (~1%, atomic fraction); over-addition reverses the benefit |
Hf[42,69] | HfO2-containing scale or dispersed Hf-rich oxides; denser and more adherent multilayer architecture containing scale or dispersed Hf | Markedly improves scale adhesion, suppresses spallation, stabilizes protective layers | Increases density and cost; excessive Hf complicates phase constitution |
B[36,44] | Alters oxidation response mainly through microstructure/eutectic modification, not by forming a dominant oxide | Refines microstructure and helps construct a more uniform oxidation pathway | Very narrow window; excess B increases silicide fraction, impairing toughness and oxidation balance |
Rare-earth element[45-54] | Forms stable rare-earth oxides or complex oxides (e.g., ErNbO4); denser and more adherent scale | Reactive element effect: improves adhesion, suppresses cracking/spallation, reduces oxygen diffusion, purifies interfaces | Effective only at trace/low levels; over-addition forms coarse oxides/inclusions that degrade integrity |