医用可降解锌合金的生物相容性评价研究进展
王鲁宁, 尹玉霞, 石章智, 韩倩倩

Research Progress on Biocompatibility Evaluation of Biomedical Degradable Zinc Alloys
WANG Luning, YIN Yuxia, SHI Zhangzhi, HAN Qianqian
表5 可降解与传统金属植入器械/材料在细胞毒性试验中的异同
Table 5 Similarities and differences between degradable and traditional metal implanted devices/materials in cytotoxicity tests
ItemTraditional metal implant devices/materialsDegradable metal implant devices/materials
Material typeStainless steel, nickel-titanium alloy, cobalt-chromium alloy, titanium alloy, etc.Zn alloy, Mg alloy, Fe alloy, etc.
PropertyInertBioactive

Principle

Support, occupy space, etc., by physical properties to achieve clinical therapeutic effectsPhysical properties function in the early stage, then the materials degrade and the target lesion tissue remodels gradually

Potential source

of cytotoxicity

Processing aids, leachablesProcessing aids, leachables, degradation products (ions), pH, osmotic pressure, surface energy, etc.
Sterilization methodNot limited to ethylene oxide (EO), irradiation sterilization, etc.Methods with minimal impact on material properties
Evaluation endpointMorphological evaluation, cell growth ability, and metabolic characteristics (microscopic observation + MTT method, etc.)

Contact way

Extraction method, direct or indirect contact method can be selected according to the principle of "closest to the application situation". Generally, the extraction method is recommendedExtraction method, direct or indirect contact method can be selected according to the principle of "closest to the application situation"

Extraction

medium

The ability to support cell growth and to extract both polar and non-polar substancesCell culture medium with serum, generally. The ratio of serum can be adjusted according to the effect of serum on the material

Extraction condition

Generally (37 ± 1)oC, (24 ± 2) h

The appropriate extraction time can be selected according to the implantation time, degradation rate and degradation products in vivo. Evaluation of multiple extraction times are also necessary to fully understand and assess biological risks
Extraction ratio(Surface area or mass / volume) ± 10%
ExtractionDilution is not recommended generallyMultiple dilutions may be necessary
Extraction treatmentAdjustment is not recommended generallyFiltration, centrifugation, pH adjustment, etc., can be used, but treatment should be recorded and evaluated

Cell line

Suitable cell lines recognized by ISO experts, such as mouse fibroblast CCL1 (L929), mouse embryonic fibroblast CCL163 (Balb/3T3 clone A31), etc. L929 cells are generally used in ChinaDepending on the application site, sensitivity- or site-specific cells may be required to evaluate their cellular responses more objectively